The sisters' estranged father returns, but trouble arises when he teams up with the new neighbors, who are actually shape-shifters trying to steal the Book of Shadows. Meanwhile, a handyman comes to the manor to help the girls.
The sisters are going to a party at the new neighbors house. Prue is reluctant to go but is coaxed into staying. There, they run into Andy, Prue's "friend". Andy asks Prue out to a basketball game, but she declines. Prue goes home and finds more