News

by kendra Send a Compliment at 11:57 PDT, 21 June, 2009

Father's Day Duke-out: And the Winner Is... - Featured

| loading


And our winner is Nathan Scott of One Tree Hill! The Simpsons' Homer Simpson was a close 2nd with Sandy Cohn of The O.C. in third. Thanks for all your votes and participation!


*************************************************************


You all voted for your favorite dad in Round 1 from the list of nominated dads. So from your votes in Round 1, we're down to the top 20 for Round 2!


Check out the top 20 dads below, then comment with your #1 favorite dad from the list! The winner will be announced Monday afternoon, so don't forget to find out if your fav dad won.


Sandy Cohen - The O.C.

Nathan Scott - One Tree Hill

John Winchester - Supernatural

The Doctor - Doctor Who

Homer Simpson - The Simpsons

Coach Eric Taylor - Friday Night Lights

Keith Mars - Veronica Mars

Red Foreman - That 70's Show

Randy Marsh - South Park

Angel - Angel

Rupert Giles - Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Peter Griffin - Family Guy

Seeley Booth - Bones

Hal Wilkerson - Malcolm in the Middle

Jed Bartlett - The West Wing

Michael Bluth - Arrested Development

Ted Mosby - How I Met Your Mother

Hank Moody - Californication

Tim Taylor - Home Improvement

Jack Bristow - Alias


Happy Father's Day to all real and TV dads!


last edited by kendra Send a Compliment at 13:37 PDT, 22 June, 2009

  • Share on Facebook
  • Stumble It!

Comments (92 comments)

  1. dooood dooood Send a Compliment - 12:06 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    and the winner is....... (drumroll)



    ....

    ....


    HOMER SIMPSON


    (cheering)

  2. Faramay Faramay Send a Compliment - 12:09 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Nathan Scott from One Tree Hill is a really good TV Dad... His scenes with Jamie are so cute!

  3. DosSin Send a Compliment - 12:21 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    I'm gonna have to go with...


    Jack Bristow


    and with a close second...


    The Doctor

  4. cds2005 Send a Compliment - 12:25 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    coach eric taylor

  5. clothes-ovr-bros clothes-ovr-bros Send a Compliment - 12:48 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Nathan Scott - One Tree Hill


    His and Jamie's relationship is so sweet, he's definitly the best dad.

  6. Shamako Shamako Send a Compliment - 12:52 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Michael Bluth - Arrested Development

  7. senpaiiry Send a Compliment - 13:25 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Sandy cohen all the way!

  8. dila123 dila123 Send a Compliment - 13:28 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Homer Simpson

  9. barneystinsonfan barneystinsonfan Send a Compliment - 13:44 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Sandy Cohen

  10. bengela bengela Send a Compliment - 13:45 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Michael Bluth was a great dad... except for in naming his son. Great son, too, in working with what he had... which was pretty much dysfunctional all around.

  11. StefyG StefyG Send a Compliment - 13:46 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    num 1: TED MOSBY !!!!!!



    num 2: HOMER SIMPSON !!!!

  12. lolabellies137 lolabellies137 Send a Compliment - 13:54 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Keith Mars

  13. dyingangel259 dyingangel259 Send a Compliment - 14:02 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Tim Taylor :)


    Mainly cuz he reminds me of my own father

  14. LivLemon LivLemon Send a Compliment - 14:35 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    The best tv dad is Sandy Cohen!! He's such a great dad, and such a good guy... it's impossible not to love him and want him to be your own dad!

  15. Jesshayes Jesshayes Send a Compliment - 14:35 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Sandy Cohen


    The funniest TV dad ever (except possibly eugene levy) is George from the secret life.

  16. shanicexx shanicexx Send a Compliment - 14:40 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    It has to be Nathan Scott! x

  17. Destiel Destiel Send a Compliment - 14:42 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    John Winchester!

  18. moni_d moni_d Send a Compliment - 14:48 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Awww! George Lopez isn't on the list.


    Well, if I had to choose, it'd be Red Foreman because he portrays dad's everywhere.

  19. FireFly_2 FireFly_2 Send a Compliment - 15:04 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Hal Wilkerson - Malcolm in the Middle

  20. otty1994 otty1994 Send a Compliment - 15:20 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    NATHAN Scott

    ofcourse only because his son Jamie is adorable!!!


  21. hagfish hagfish Send a Compliment - 15:36 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Tim 'the Toolman' Taylor - Home Improvement


    No one else combines absolute silliness and destruction with good parenting.

  22. razam razam Send a Compliment - 15:36 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Homer

  23. harleywright harleywright Send a Compliment - 15:56 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    homer for sure

  24. gracieq915 gracieq915 Send a Compliment - 16:18 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Micheal Bluth

  25. clarkie4ever clarkie4ever Send a Compliment - 16:31 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Michael Bluth

  26. rubysnides rubysnides Send a Compliment - 16:44 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    sandy cohen takes it

  27. x9mj73l8 x9mj73l8 Send a Compliment - 16:57 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Red Foreman!

  28. gotsushi319 gotsushi319 Send a Compliment - 17:04 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    red foreman or nathan scott

  29. meredith5990 meredith5990 Send a Compliment - 17:15 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Nathan Scott

  30. yoyo3772 yoyo3772 Send a Compliment - 18:40 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Ahhhh this is hard descion to make AHHH! My say would be Seeley Booth him and Parker look great together. But my next ones would be Angel, Nathan Scott, or John Winchester.

  31. ak10 ak10 Send a Compliment - 18:40 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Homer J. Simpson

  32. Jadia405 Jadia405 Send a Compliment - 18:40 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Red Foreman, Dumba**!!!

  33. Monkey10705 Send a Compliment - 19:29 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Nathan Scott

  34. bailey1297 bailey1297 Send a Compliment - 20:42 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    1) Nathan Scott

    2) Seeley Booth

  35. bart Send a Compliment - 20:50 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Coach Eric Taylor.

  36. JustWillow JustWillow Send a Compliment - 20:58 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Rupert Giles (even though he's not technically a dad)

  37. spongebob420 spongebob420 Send a Compliment - 21:07 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    RANDY MARSH HANDS DOWN

  38. SweetyBella23 SweetyBella23 Send a Compliment - 21:19 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    I vote to Nathan Scott. He's the cutest daddy ever!!!

  39. Oscar-BM Oscar-BM Send a Compliment - 21:29 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Hank Moody all the way.

  40. xander574 Send a Compliment - 21:35 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    hank moody

  41. LithiumRox LithiumRox Send a Compliment - 21:51 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    ANGEL all the way


    ( love the fact that DB is on here twice ^_^ And that Giles is on here even though he isn't really anyone's father. He's the best father-figure a Slayer could ask for.)

  42. ldewald Send a Compliment - 22:08 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Keith Mars!

  43. Slyfox51090 Slyfox51090 Send a Compliment - 23:10 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Two Words HOMER SIMPSON!!

  44. ilovetv88 ilovetv88 Send a Compliment - 23:18 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Nathan Scott!!

  45. Megaman280 Send a Compliment - 23:41 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Michael Bluth baby all day

  46. Streamline Streamline Send a Compliment - 23:50 PDT, 21 June, 2009

    Michael Bluth

  47. Sklib Send a Compliment - 0:14 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Randy Marsh

  48. PoojaT Send a Compliment - 1:02 PDT, 22 June, 2009
  49. totvornottotv totvornottotv Send a Compliment - 1:30 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    coach taylor and jack bristow

  50. Mercury7jg Mercury7jg Send a Compliment - 2:06 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Red Foreman

  51. Yasminde Yasminde Send a Compliment - 3:49 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    John Winchester!

  52. chupa_chups Send a Compliment - 4:04 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Coach Eric Taylor who else!? He's not just a great dad to his own kids but also to the whole Team of the Dillon Panthers! Way to go!!!

  53. Soothsayer Soothsayer Send a Compliment - 6:02 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    John Winchester

  54. impulsivegyal impulsivegyal Send a Compliment - 6:24 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Sandy Cohen def one of the greatest TV dads!!

  55. npthuluv Send a Compliment - 6:28 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Sandy Cohen is an AMAZING father in that he actually parents (I don't know if that's a verb or not lol).

  56. soul23 Send a Compliment - 6:29 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    sandy cohen

  57. demondogx demondogx Send a Compliment - 7:35 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    red foreman

  58. xxajxx xxajxx Send a Compliment - 7:36 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    definately HOMER SIMPSON!!!!:)

  59. Freakedout Freakedout Send a Compliment - 7:38 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Homer Simpson - The Simpsons

  60. lightyagami lightyagami Send a Compliment - 7:40 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Hank Moody/ Randy Marsh

  61. vddreux2 vddreux2 Send a Compliment - 7:46 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    1. eric taylor

    2. sandy cohen

  62. D&GgIRL<3 D&GgIRL<3 Send a Compliment - 8:02 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Tim Taylor

  63. LordJohn LordJohn Send a Compliment - 8:23 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Michael Bluth/Hank Moody

  64. DanielR Send a Compliment - 8:33 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Definitely HOMER SIMPSON!!!

  65. sepiatonelovin sepiatonelovin Send a Compliment - 8:33 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Coach Eric Taylor all the way!


    I want him to be my dad lol!

  66. lhibbard Send a Compliment - 8:35 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Nathan Scott

  67. nobodyuseful Send a Compliment - 8:49 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    100 % Peter Griffin from Family Guy

  68. b_real b_real Send a Compliment - 9:13 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Hal from Malcom

  69. mundham mundham Send a Compliment - 9:23 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Homer Simpson

  70. dragonstar8707 dragonstar8707 Send a Compliment - 9:47 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    john winchester

  71. heehawmcgraw heehawmcgraw Send a Compliment - 10:01 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Jeb Bartlett

  72. Rachelia Rachelia Send a Compliment - 10:21 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Rupert Giles!

  73. thatcoldnight thatcoldnight Send a Compliment - 10:43 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Michael Bluth

  74. VMars4ever VMars4ever Send a Compliment - 10:52 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Nathan Scott

  75. VMars4ever VMars4ever Send a Compliment - 10:53 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Nathan Scott

  76. janemylow janemylow Send a Compliment - 11:13 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    How can there be any question? Obviously the best TV dad is Sandy Cohen!

  77. zonezero Send a Compliment - 11:18 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Homer Simpson - The Simpsons FTW

  78. khalilsgirl1 khalilsgirl1 Send a Compliment - 11:47 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    nathan scott- One Tree Hill

  79. sarrypotter sarrypotter Send a Compliment - 11:52 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Keith Mars

  80. Sammyyy Sammyyy Send a Compliment - 12:17 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Keith Mars !

  81. nooranyehia nooranyehia Send a Compliment - 12:23 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Michael bluth

  82. npthuluv Send a Compliment - 12:29 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Sandy Cohen

  83. npthuluv Send a Compliment - 12:30 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Sandy Cohen

  84. npthuluv Send a Compliment - 12:32 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Sandy Cohen

  85. beachychic23 Send a Compliment - 12:50 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    nathan scott

  86. MattF Send a Compliment - 13:15 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    JOHN WINCHESTER!

  87. S0ph0ia S0ph0ia Send a Compliment - 13:16 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Angel

  88. papoila papoila Send a Compliment - 13:32 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Coach Eric Taylor

  89. kirkman Send a Compliment - 16:20 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    Homer Simpson!!!!!!!!

  90. KanaKatasrophe KanaKatasrophe Send a Compliment - 20:17 PDT, 22 June, 2009

    John Winchester for sure!

    All he's done for his boys. :D

  91. kaci19 kaci19 Send a Compliment - 16:09 PDT, 23 June, 2009

    has to be sandy cohen!!! he's such a good dad and took ryan in too.

    then secon for me would be tim the tool man taylor lol, he's good dad and so silly.


    can i just say though why is ted moseby on the list coz we never see him being a dad so i dont think you can really judge

  92. Fly_Away Fly_Away Send a Compliment - 17:02 PDT, 23 June, 2009

    JOHN WINCHESTER

Add a Comment and to share it with your friends.