hi just a short question but is charlie dead? as he is pointed out to hurley by tht mental patient and then he just dissapears i mean ino hes a tad mental but how can another person point him out unless hes real it confused me to the max lol

anyways if any can compliment me by giving me answers id be uber grateful as in my eyes i cant think of a logical answer unless he was there lmao

JaCKirY