'American Idol' Top 12: Pia Toscano nails Whitney, Haley Reinhart fumbles Whitney


The "American Idol" live show kicked off with a tastefully done little PSA for the relief effort for Japan. If you download any of the songs from tonight's show, the proceeds go to the Red Cross, plus there will be a way to donate during the results show tomorrow night. That's cool.The judges come out and - hey, Carly Smithson is there! Loved her in Season 7. Steven Tyler is dressed especially gypsy-like, while J.Lo is a jungle cat with a mane of hair.Seacrest tell us that tonight's theme is Birth Year, which is always fun because A) we get to see photos/video of the Idols are babies and B) it's funny that some of them were born in like 2003. Not really, but it kinda seems that way sometimes.Here are the Idols, from best to worst:Safe Idols1. Pia Toscano, "Where Do Broken Hearts Go" by Whitney Houston (1988) Looking super 80s/current hot, Pia gets...



Want to comment on this? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!