'American Idol,' Season 11, Episode 14, Female Semifinalists Perform: TV Recap. Tonight, the 12 remaining girls, including one Hallie, one Haley and one Hollie, took the stage on "American Idol," but by the end of tomorrow night’s show only half will remain. The guys gave it their best shot last night. The judges, Steven Tyler, Randy Jackson and Jennifer Lopez, were much, much harder on the girls and more open with their criticism. Asked to compare by Ryan Seacrest, JLo and Randy (in between "yo’s") suggested the excitement of the first night might have caused them to let a few guys slide.