The new SideReel iOS app features a fresh design and improved Tracker. Get the SideReel App!  

CLOSED!! Vile Villains: Who's the Most Evil TV Villain? Vote in ROUND 1 - Featured

Voting for ROUND 1 is NOW CLOSED! Vote now in Round 2!



In honor of this deliciously creepy time of year, we want to know your favorite TV villains that are deliciously creepy just about all year round!


Here's how it works:

To vote, comment with the names of the 8 villains that you believe would emerge victorious in the first match-ups shown in the bracket above (click for a larger image).


Voting will run Wednesday 10/28 - Thursday evening 10/29. Round 2 will then begin based on your Round 1 votes! Votes will be accepted in the comments of this post and via comments on our Tweets and Facebook post about this ultimate vile villain showdown.


Go forth and make your spooktacular votes!

Comments

| 21:05 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusDr. JonesSmokey SylarMaryannLew Luther Damon
| 19:18 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
SYLAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! dark Willow,the mayor,dr. jonessmokey SYLARRRRRRRRRRTrinity killerdan scottdamon SYLARSYLARSYLARSYLAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
| 19:06 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
SylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylarSylar
| 18:53 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusDr. JonesSloane SylarMaryannLex LuthorYellow- Eyed Demon
| 18:02 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
sylar all the waysylarsylarsylarsylarsylarsylarsylar
| 18:02 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
sylar all the waysylarsylarsylarsylarsylarsylarsylar
| 17:38 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelousBenSloanSylarMaryannLex LuthorDamon
| 17:27 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusJonesSmokeySylarTrinity KillerLex LuthorYellow Eyes
| 16:33 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Angelus Ben (who should get a final showdown with Lex Luthor in finals) Smokey Sylar Maryann Lex Luthor Damon
| 16:12 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
ben smokey angelus dark willow sylar trinity killer lex luthor damon
| 16:10 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstMaryannDamon .........
| 16:07 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSloaneSylarMaryannLex LuthorYellow-Eyed Demon
| 15:42 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowThe Mayor (this was hard, if they had been on opposite sides i think they would have been the final two)Dr. JonesAlphaDan Scott
| 15:26 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBenSmokeySylarTrinity KillerDan ScottYellow Eyed Demon
| 15:06 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WilliowAngelusDr. JonesSmokeySylarMaryannLex LuthorYellowed Eyed Demon
| 14:58 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
simple Damon and Ben of Lost
| 14:54 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSmokeySylarMaryannaLex LuthorDamon
| 14:52 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
the firstangelus (fer sure)sylarmaryannlex lutherand crapppppp this ones really harddddd ...but i guess yelloew eyed demon
| 14:22 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
SYLAR!!!! (GREATEST EVILNESS EVAAAAAR!!!!!)TrinityDan ScottYallow-Eyed DemonFirstMayorBenSloanne
| 14:20 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
yellow eyed demonlex luthertrinity killeralphasmokeydr jonesthe mayordark willow
| 13:39 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
the firstangelus (though one mayor was pretty evil too)bensloane sylar( alpha's not evil he is just crazy...)maryanndan scottyellow eyed demon!
| 13:33 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Only putting votes out for Sylar, Lex and Azazel (Yellow Eyed Demon)
| 13:32 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
the firstthe mayorbesloan SYLARtrinity killerlex luthoryellow eyed demon
| 12:46 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
the firstangelusbensloane alphano votelexyellow-eyed demon
| 12:39 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Sylar and Lex. other than those two IDC
| 12:13 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBenSmokeyAlphaMaryannLex LuthorYellow-Eyed Demon
| 12:04 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
dark willowthe mayorbensloanesylarmaryannlex luthoryellow eyed demon
| 11:57 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSloaneSylarMaryannLex Luthoryellow-eyed demon
| 11:50 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelus (it was hard to choose!)Alpha (he's an evil genius...can't really say the same for Sylar)MaryannDamon I haven't really seen enough of the other shows to make informed decisions. How did no one from Stargate make the lists?
| 11:49 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBenSmokey SylarMaryannLex LuthorYellow Eyed Demon
| 11:32 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
dark willowangelusbensloanesylarmaryannlex luthoryellow eyed demon
| 11:27 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
dark willowangelusdr jonessloanesylarmaryannyellow eyed demon
| 11:19 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBenSloaneSylar[no vote]Lex LuthorYellow-Eyed Demon (cuz lets face it, we all know that Azazel is one bad-a** villain)
| 11:16 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The First Angelus Ben Sloane Alpha Maryann Lex Yellow-eyes
| 09:55 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
SylarDamonMaryAnnSloane
| 09:53 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Sylar!!!
| 09:52 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusDr. JonesSloaneSylarTrinity KillerLex LuthorYellow-eyed Demon
| 09:40 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBenSloaneSylarTrinity KillerLex LuthorDamon If we are talking about the most evil and not the most powerful Angelus or Sylar would win everytime!!!
| 09:07 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Lex LuthonYellow-Eyed DemonDamonDr.JonesSylarMaryannAlphaDark Willow
| 08:42 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBenSmoky SylarMaryannLex LuthorYellow-Eyed Demon
| 08:24 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSloane SylarMaryannLex LuthorYellow-eyed Demon
| 07:35 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSmokeySylarMaryannDan ScottYelow eyed demon
| 07:30 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusDr JonesSloaneSylarDan ScottYellow eyed demon
| 07:19 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
SylarmaryannDan ScottYellow-Eyed demonDark WillowAngelusBenSmokey
| 07:06 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSmokeySylarMaryannLex LuthorDamon
| 07:04 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
dark willowangelusbensloanesylarmaryannno voteyellow eyed demon
| 06:54 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSmokeyAlphaTrinity KillerNo VoteYellow Eyed Demon
| 06:43 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
SylarBenLex Luther i don t know anyone else
| 06:26 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusNo voteNo voteSylarNo voteLex LuthorYellow eyed demon
| 06:02 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
dark willowangelusbensloanesylartrinity killerlex luthoryellow ...
| 05:49 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
the firstanglelusbensloanesylartrinitylexdamon
| 05:20 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
dark willowthe mayorbensmokysylartrinitylexyellow
| 05:17 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSloaneSylarTrinityLexYellow-Eyed
| 04:56 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBen LinusSmokeySylarMaryann/Trinity Killer (I wouldn't know don't watch either)Lex LuthorYellow eyed demon/Damon (again don't watch either).
| 04:46 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSmokeyAlphaTrinity KillerLex LuthorYellow-Eyed Demon If there were no second, third or fourth season of Heroes, I would have said Sylar. And even though season 4 of Dexter isn't over, Maryann was only evil because she was unstoppable. But if you include the fourth season of Angel in the ranking of Angelus, then there is no question.
| 04:16 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowThe MayorBenSloaneSylarMaryannDan ScottDamon
| 04:09 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
No VoteSylarLex LuthorBenSloaneNo VoteMaryanne (I looove Dexter, and Trinity seems brutal, but Maryann has been killing b*tches for centuries and basically sacrifices them to the devil.)No Vote
| 03:55 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Ben, Smokey, Sylar, Trinity Killer, Lex Luther, Yellow Eyed Demon
| 03:53 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The First, Angelus, Dr Jones, Sloanne, Alpha, Trinity Killer, Lex Luther, Yellow Eyes Demon
| 03:52 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow -BtVS - | Sylar - Heroes The Mayor - BtVS - | Maryann - True Blood Ben -Lost - | Lex Luther - Smallville Sloane - Alias - | Damon - Vampire Diaries
| 03:47 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
None (for willow and the first)Angelus Ben LinusSloane SylarThe Trinity Lex LuthorYellow Eyes
| 03:40 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Simon Adebisi - ozWindom Earle - Twin PeaksMarlo Stanfield - The Wiretony sopranoAl Swearengen - Deadwood
| 03:01 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The First - BtVS The Mayor - BtVS Ben - Lost Sloane - Alias Trinity Killer - Dexter Lex Luthor - Smallville Yellow eyed demon - Supernatural Alpha - Dollhouse
| 02:47 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBen (He's not the most powerful but he is the most evil"Smokey (Really? Sloane?)Sylar (Dude can't die)The Trinity KillerLex LuthorYellow Eyed Demon (Aren't demons the definition of evil?) Also, all the "BTVS" characters in the same matchups is because, if you take note of the larger, bold font words in the brackets, that's their division
| 02:31 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AlphaTrinity KillerDan ScottYellow Eyed DemonDark WillowThe MayorDr. JonesSloanewhy did you have to pair up all the BTVS chars in the same matchups?
| 02:26 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Ben Linus, for sure.the Yellow-Eyed Demon from Supernatural (he DOES have a name... Azazel. XD)Sylarthe Trinity Killer (I haven't seen Dexter, but Maryann was lame as all hell. so screw her.)
| 02:23 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBen?SylarMaryanndont watchdont watch
| 01:46 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow AlphaAngelus MaryAnne Dr. Jones Lex LuthorSloane Damon
| 01:38 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusDr. JonesSloaneAlphaTrinity KillerLex LuthorYellow Eyed Demon
| 01:16 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBenDr. SloaneSylarMaryannDan ScottDamon
| 01:16 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSmokey SylarMaryannLex LuthorDamon
| 01:12 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSmokeyAlphaTrinity KillerLex LuthorYellow-Eye Demon
| 01:04 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Firstangelousbensylarlexand yellow eyes
| 00:35 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowThe MayorBenSloaneSylarTrinity Killer[no answer]Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 00:33 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusSylarMaryannDamon
| 00:31 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dr JonesSloaneSylarLex Luthor
| 00:30 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSloaneSylarTrinity KillerLex LuthorDamon
| 00:19 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow - (My bets are down on this one) Angelus Ben Sloane Sylar maryann Dan Scott - C'mon the guy shot his own brother at point blank Yellow Eyed Demon - mmmm...drops of demon blood anyone?
| 00:17 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The First vs Willow - The FirstThe Mayor vs Angelus - AngelusBen vs Dr Jones - Cant remember Dr Jones so ... (No Vote)Solane vs Smokey - (No Vote)Sylar vs Alpha - Hmmm Season 1 Sylar? then Sylar, Post season 1, then AlphaMaryann vs Trinity Killer - (No Vote)Lex Luthor vs Dan Scott - Lex Luthor was lame but I havent watched One Tree Hill....so Dan ScottDamon vs Yellow-Eyed Demon - Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 00:13 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Yellow Eyes-SupernaturalLex Luthor-SmallvilleSylar-heroesMaryann-True bloodDamon-Vampire DiariesDark Willow-BtVS
| 00:07 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
BenSylarandMayann (though that one is an unfair fight)
| 00:03 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBenSmokeySylarMaryannDan ScottYellow-Eyed Demon
| 00:03 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSloanSylarMaryannLex LuthorYellow-Eyed Demon
| 00:02 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusDr JonesSloaneSylarMaryannLexYellow Eyed Demon
| 23:55 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
MaryannalphaLexYellow eyed demondark willowangelusdr.jonessloane
| 23:54 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow!!!!!!!!! V.S. Angelus <--- This would be truly epic.Ben V.S. Sloane <-- The ultimate in manipulations! But what would be better would be Irina Derevko VS Ben!!!!!!! IMAGINE!Alpha V.S. Trinity KillerLex Luthor V.S. Damon
| 23:50 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Sylar by far the besttrinity killerlex luthoryellow eyed demondark willowangelusdr,jonessloane
| 23:37 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSmokeySylarTrinity KillerLex LuthorYellow-Eyed Demon
| 23:13 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WIllow -BTVSThe First-BTVSAngelus-BTVSSylar-HeroesAlpha-DollhouseLex Luthor- SmallvilleThe Mayor - BTVS
| 23:09 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelesBenSloaneSylarMaryannLex LutherDmon
| 22:57 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
dark willowangelousbensalonesylarTrinty Killer (the guy gives me the creeps)lex lutherDamon
| 22:54 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
the firstangelusbenthe smoke monsteralphadexterlex lutheryellow eyed demon
| 22:52 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
dark willowangelousdr. jonessloanesylarmaryanndan scottdamon
| 22:44 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSloaneSylarMaryannLexneither- write in for cole
| 22:36 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
LEX LUTHERDAN SCOTT ..those are the only ones that i think have serious eeeevil in them! what about - COLE TURNER (Charmed) (who was bathazor, then the source [of all evil!])
| 22:27 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSloaneSylarTrinityLex LuthorYED
| 22:16 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowThe MayorBenSloaneSylarMaryannLexYellow Eyed Demon
| 22:14 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBenSmokeyAlphaMaryannLex LutherYellow-eyed demon
| 22:11 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow-BtvsAngelus-BtvsYellow eyed demon - SupernaturalSylar - HeroesDamon - Vampire DiariesMaryann - True BloodTrinity Killer - DexterAlpha - Dollhouse
| 22:08 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSloaneSylarMaryannLex LuthorDamon
| 22:07 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
the firstthe mayordr. jonessloanesylarmaryanndan scottyellow eyed demon
| 22:05 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusDr. JonesSmokeySylarMaryannLex LuthorYellow-Eyed Demon
| 21:58 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
the firstthe mayorbensmokeyalphamaryannlex luthor
| 21:47 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
dark willowangelusbenSloanesylarTrinityLexDamon
| 21:39 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSmoke MonsterAlphaTrinityLex LutherDamon
| 21:39 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSloaneAplhaTrinityLexYellow eyes
| 21:32 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSmoke MonsterSylarWe don't know enough about the Trinity killer yet, so maryanne by default, but YUCKLex LUUUUUUthorYellow Eyes, (Azeyzel)
| 21:29 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Maryann will come out victorious as long as her opponent has some kind of urge or desire for violence, greed, gluttony... etc.
| 21:21 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Sylar definitely, he killed both of his parents
| 21:20 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelusBenSmokeySylarTrinity KillerLex Luthor (come on, that one was TOO easy)Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 21:20 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
The FirstAngelusBenSloan AlphaMaryannLexYellow-eyes
| 21:12 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
The FirstThe MayorBenSloane Sylar[no vote][no vote]Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 21:11 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Oh and i forgot Lex Luthor
| 21:10 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowThe MayorBen LinusSloane SYLER Trinity KillerDamon
| 21:09 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
The First - BtVSThe Mayor - BtVSBen - LostSloane - AliasTrinity Killer - DexterLex Luthor - Smallville (Awesome actor please bring him back he made the show)Yellow eyed demon - SupernaturalAlpha - Dollhouse (Please let us see more of him this season, and Sylar was great season 1 by isn't remotely creepy anymore)
| 21:07 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Sylar.Hands down. He slices people's skulls open to analyze their abilities by picking through their minds.A cold-blooded murderer, and all around awesome psychopath.Does it get any better?
| 20:57 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Sylar - HeroesBen Linus - LostDan Scott - One Tree HillSloane - AliasThe Mayor - BtVSThe First - BtVSDamon - Vampire DiariesMaryann - True Blood
| 20:56 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowAngelus (and the Mayor! Why couldn't they be in different blocks???)SloaneSylarLex Luthor ...but mostly Angelus.
| 20:55 EDT, 28 Oct, 2009
Caleb ( Nathan Fillion ) The evil preacher on season 7 of Buffy should be up there. Dude was pure Evil.

Post Comment

Want to comment on this post? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!