This round is now complete! Vote in the Final Round:
So now it's time for Round 2 in which you Reelers will determine who goes up against Jensen Ackles in the hottie finals.
For Round 2, the #2 and #3 nominees face off: Ian Somerhalder of Vampire Diaries vs. Jared Padalecki of Supernatural!
Add your vote for one of these two CW gentlemen in the comments below!
The voting will run Friday afternoon (1/22) through Monday morning (1/25). The final round will then begin to determine the hottest CW boy of all!