The new SideReel iOS app features a fresh design and improved Tracker. Get the SideReel App!  

CLOSED!! Vile Villains: Who's the Most Evil TV Villain? Vote in ROUND 2 - Featured

Voting for ROUND 2 is CLOSED! Vote now in Round 3!



In honor of this deliciously creepy time of year, we want to know your favorite TV villains that are deliciously creepy just about all year round!


From the results of Round 1, we're down to 4 match-ups of the most worthy/favorite of Vile Villains for Round 2!


Here's how it works:


To vote, comment with the names of the 4 villains that you believe would emerge victorious in the 2nd round of match-ups shown in the bracket above (click for a larger image).


Voting for Round 2 will run Thursday afternoon 10/29 - Friday evening 10/30. Round 3 will then begin based on your Round 2 votes! Votes will be accepted in the comments of this post and via comments on our Tweets and Facebook post about this ultimate vile villain showdown.

Comments

| 20:33 EST, 04 Nov, 2009
sylar is like the best villian ever cant die and hes out his mind mary ann come on she was just crazy no real power sylar got i all.but sylar and yellow eyes would be great!
| 20:27 EDT, 31 Oct, 2009
Angelus Ben Sylar Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 17:46 EDT, 31 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowBenMaryannYellow-Eyed Demon
| 22:30 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneSylarYellow-Eyed Demon
| 19:52 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowSylarYellow eyesSloane my favourite of all is already and with now doubt SYLAR, by the way the ONLY reason to still watch Heroes...
| 19:08 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
dark willowyellow eyessylarslone
| 18:48 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
angelussloanesylarlex
| 18:45 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow! Yellow-Eyed Demon Sloane Sylar
| 18:44 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WilliowBenMaryannYellow Eyed Demon
| 18:41 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowYellow-Eyed DemBenSylar
| 18:19 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Maryann Yellow Eyed Demon Sloane
| 17:51 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Ben Syler Lex
| 17:27 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
My votes are:Angelus,Sloane,MaryAnnYellow-eyed deamon... Long live Alias! :)
| 17:23 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
-Angelus-Ben-Sylar-Lex Luther
| 17:13 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
-Angelus -Sloane -Sylar -Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 17:09 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneSylarYellow Eyed Demon
| 16:57 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenMaryannLex Luthor
| 16:13 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Sloane Sylar Yellow Eyed Demon
| 16:10 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Lex L Angelus Ben --None--
| 16:08 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
angelus maryann and lex
| 15:44 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Yellow Eyed Demon Sylar Angelus Ben
| 15:42 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
sloansylarlex luthor
| 15:41 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Sloane Maryann Yellow Eyed Demon
| 15:37 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Ben Sylar Lex Luthor
| 15:25 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Sloane Lex Luther Sylar
| 15:22 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowSloaneSylarYellow Eyes
| 15:13 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowSloaneMaryannYellow Eyes
| 14:57 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
DARK WILLOW (im a total fan of Angel, but Dark Willow has got some powers on the OTHER level!)Sloane\SylarLex Luthor
| 14:55 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowSloaneSylarYellow Eyes
| 14:21 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus!!!! He would beat them all! (Totally evil, remember when the judge touched him and he said there was no humanity in him!)Sloane - he would manipulate ben into somehow working for him and ultimately kill himSylar- Just because, maryann was not "evil" for the sake of being evil she was a slave to her god... also she creeps me out and sylar is awesomeYellow eyed Demon- Demon... no contest against a rich bald guy Dark willow is prob more powerful, but she lacks the pure "evilness" and taps out magic pretty quick. Goddess WIllow would be more of a fight!
| 14:18 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Ben Sylar Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 14:15 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowBenSylarLex Luthor
| 14:13 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneSylarThe Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 14:00 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
DARK WILLOW, although I love angel/angelus the very fact that Dark Willow could control objects with her mind would result in a quick steaking. Sloane - would have some Rimbaldi device or contraption to squash Ben Sylar - again with the telekinesis The Yellow Eyed Demon - C'mon Lex is just a twisted spoiled rich kid who like to experiment on meteor freaks, The Yellow Eyed Demon, is well, a DEMON.... 'Nough Said. Ultimately though, no contest. Dark Willow as she can summon all the magic on the freakin' planet.
| 13:47 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Sloane Maryann Yellow eyed Demon
| 13:31 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Ben Sylar Yellow Eyed Demon
| 13:16 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Lex Luthor Ben Sylar
| 13:02 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Maryann Ben Yellow-eyed demon Dark Willow
| 12:51 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willo, Ben, Sylar, Yellow-Eyed-Demon
| 12:50 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Ben Maryann Lex Luthor
| 12:46 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Maryann Sylar Lex
| 12:45 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow (please be the winner! :P)SloaneMaryannLex Luthor
| 12:44 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus (way more evil, sadistic, nasty, not nearly as hot) Sloane Sylar (though they keep trying to make him all cuddly, keep him nasty, that's why we fell in love with him in the first place!) Yellow-Eyed Demon (look up Azaezel biblicaly, he's pretty darn interesting)
| 12:39 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus, Ben, Lex, Maryann
| 12:35 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Ben Syler <3 :D GO HEROES! Lex Luthor
| 12:20 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow,Ben SylarYellow Eyes (Planned out the end of the world. Evil SOB with all capital letters in evil)
| 12:11 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
SylarLex LuthorSloaneDark Willow
| 12:07 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
dark willow Sylar Yellow Eyed Demon sloane
| 12:03 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneSylarYellow Eyed Demon
| 11:42 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
dark willowsloanemary-annyellow-eyed demon
| 11:41 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus - Have to agree with the comments: Dark Willow ridiculously powerful but not really the most "vile" villain. It's if Peter from Heroes decided to kill his brother to stop future suffering... =P Anger corrupts judgments but the intention wasn't corrupt. Ben - only because I don't know the other person Sylar - means, motive, and opportunity Yellow Eyed Demon - demons are meant to be evil right?
| 11:31 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowBenSylar <3Yellow-Eyed Demon :)
| 11:29 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus also nearly ended the world by opening Acathla. I love Dark Willow, but my argument for Angelus is simple. Willow had to continually borrow magic, was held at bay by both Giles and Anya, and eventually tried to end the world to stop the suffering of humanity. Angelus, on the other hand, had no humanity. He was the deadliest recorded vampire in history. He turned killing into an art, raped young girls for fun, and played mind games with his victims. In the case of Drusilla, he first made her crazy then turned her so she would be eternally insane. When all was said and done, Willow killed one person while Angelus killed thousands. If it were me, I think I'd take my chances with Willow.
| 11:28 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Sloane Sylar Lex Luthor
| 11:01 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Wow friends, I think we're all forgetting that DARK WILLOW ALMOST ENDED THE WORLD. All Angelus ever did was kill people, follow Buffy around, and be evil.If you put the two of them against each other in a fight, I don't think Angelus would stand a chance! Willow would just rip his head off by looking at him. Seriously...
| 10:54 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowSloaneMaryannLex Luthor
| 10:49 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowBenSylarYellow-Eyed Demon
| 10:46 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus (killed for the fun of it.. I mean, really, how much more scarier is that than a witch who breaks off the end of the world just because she still has friends)BenSylarYellow-Eyed Demon
| 10:34 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Ben Sylar Yellow-Eyed demon =)
| 10:10 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow-Eyed Demon
| 10:10 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowBenSylarLex Luther
| 10:00 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelussylaryellow eyed demon
| 09:54 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowBenSylarLex Luthor
| 09:50 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Sylar Yellow Eyed Demon Ben?
| 09:49 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Sloane Sylar Lex Luther
| 09:45 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
sylarbenlex luthordark willow
| 09:40 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus - Tough one but Dark Willow only killed cos she was in pain, Angelus did it for fun (Killin Ms Calender was well evil) he'd jus toy with her til her powers drained then tease her bout Tara b4 mayb finally killin her. Ben Sylar- he just doesn't die, plus he killed Elle!! Lex Luther
| 09:28 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus, Ben, Sylar, Yellow Eyed Damon
| 09:26 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Sloane Sylar Lex Luthor
| 09:18 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
-ben-dr jones-trinity killer-alpha
| 09:14 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Killers!
| 08:38 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
BENSYLARLEX LUTHOR
| 08:37 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
BENSYLARLEX LUTHOR
| 08:27 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarLex
| 08:13 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowBenyellow eyed demonsylar
| 07:57 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Ben Sylar Lex Luthor
| 07:53 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenYellow-Eyed DemonSylar
| 07:30 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowBenSylarYellow-Eyed Demon
| 07:21 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneMaryannLex Luthor
| 07:20 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusMaryannLex Luther between Ben and Sloane it's a tie...
| 07:03 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneSylarLex Luthor
| 06:58 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow-Eyed Demon
| 06:28 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Ben Sylar Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 06:00 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Sloane Sylar Lex
| 05:35 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Sloane Sylar Lex
| 04:55 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus-you want him to die but if he dies then you lose angelSloane-killing his daughter what an assSylar-evern though hes having an identity crisisYellow-Eyed Demon-he could just take over Lex Luther, and thats why he wins
| 04:06 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Williow vs. Angelus: Dark Willow Benjamin vs. Sloane: Benjamin Sylar vs. MaryAnn: Sylar (come ON. really.) Lex Luthor vs. Yellow-Eyed Demon: Yellow-Eyed Demon (ditto)
| 03:45 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
SylarYellow EyeSloaneno vote for the btvs one
| 03:44 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Sloane Sylar Yellow-eyed Demon Final: Sloane VS Sylar WINNER: Sloane Sylar is evil but conflicted (killed his mom, didn't kill guy in house of mirrors) .Sloane is pure sick and twisted evil (killed his daughter, obsessed with Rambaldi). Sloane will win if they know the show.
| 03:26 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow-Eyed Demon
| 03:23 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow Eyed Demon
| 03:16 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusSylarLex Luthor
| 03:12 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelousSloaneYellow Eyed DemonMaryann
| 03:11 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenMaryannyellow-eyed demon
| 03:06 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow-Eyed Demon
| 02:48 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow-Eyed Demon
| 02:39 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowSloanSylerYellow-eyed Demon
| 02:31 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
BenSylarYellow-Eyed Demon
| 02:28 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Ben&Maryann
| 02:08 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
BEN, LEX , SYLAR THE MAYOR
| 02:01 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowSloaneMary AnneYellow eyed demon
| 01:57 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
angelusbensylaryellow eyed demon
| 01:52 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Sloane Sylar Lex Luthor
| 01:48 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowSloaneMary AnneYellow eyed demon
| 01:48 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
angelussloanemaryannyellow-eyed demon
| 01:42 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Maryann
| 01:41 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
dark willow sloane sylar yellow eyed demon
| 01:38 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Ben Sylar Lex Luthar
| 01:38 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Ben Sylar Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 01:31 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Angelus Ben MaryAnn Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 01:30 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneLex LuthorMaryAnn
| 01:29 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowBenMaryAnnLex Luther
| 01:20 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
SylarYellow-Eyed DemonBenAngelus
| 01:18 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
No VoteSloaneSylarLex Luthor
| 01:17 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
angelussylarlex luthorben
| 01:15 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
angelussylaryellow eyes
| 01:14 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Sylar would win hands down against a True blood vampire like Mary Ann, vampire?
| 00:57 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
dark willowbenmaryannelex
| 00:52 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowSloaneYellow Eyed DemonSylar
| 00:48 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Ben Maryanne Lex Luthor
| 00:37 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusSylarSloaneLex Luthor Rooting for Angelus!
| 00:34 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
This is going to turn into a Ben and Sylar fight. But Ben will just use some sort of weird, crazy manipulation to convince Sylar to join him, and they will eventually rule the universe. Obviously
| 00:08 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
dark willow ben lex luthor maryanne
| 00:04 EDT, 30 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow Eyed Demon
| 23:49 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Angelus Ben Sylar Lex Luthor
| 23:48 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
ben
| 23:47 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Sylar, Yellow eyed demon, BEn, Dark willow
| 23:46 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Winners of these battles should be...Angelus vs Dark Willow is hard because well, you wouldn't want to kill Angelus because of Angel and Dark Willow wouldn't exactly be able to stay dark forever. Angelus would win on that. No guy from lost could be evil enough to win the fight, so in Sloane vs Ben, Sloane would win. Sylar would win hands down against a True blood vampire like Mary Ann,and Lex Luthor would beat the yellow eyed demon.
| 23:38 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Mary Ann (as long as she believes she is immortal she is) Sloane Yellow-eyed Demon
| 23:38 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Mary Ann (as long as she believes she is immortal she is) Sloane Yellow-eyed Demon
| 23:37 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Mary Ann (as long as she believes she is immortal she is) Sloane Yellow-eyed Demon
| 23:37 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Mary Ann (as long as she believes she is immortal she is) Sloane Yellow-eyed Demon
| 23:37 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Mary Ann (as long as she believes she is immortal she is) Sloane Yellow-eyed Demon
| 23:37 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Mary Ann (as long as she believes she is immortal she is) Sloane Yellow-eyed Demon
| 23:37 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Mary Ann (as long as she believes she is immortal she is) Sloane Yellow-eyed Demon
| 23:36 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Mary Ann (as long as she believes she is immortal she is) Sloane Yellow-eyed Demon
| 23:36 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Mary Ann (as long as she believes she is immortal she is) Sloane Yellow-eyed Demon
| 23:36 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Mary Ann (as long as she believes she is immortal she is) Sloane Yellow-eyed Demon
| 23:33 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow------------------------------------Maryann Sloane---------------------------------------------Lex Luthor
| 23:29 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusSylarAzazel (yellow eyed demon)and the 4th is irrelevant
| 23:25 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneSylarYellow-Eyed Demon
| 23:20 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Angelus (Willow was powerful, but Angelus was ruthless)MaryannYellow-Eyed Demon
| 23:20 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Sloan Dark Willow Yellow-Eyed Demon Sylar
| 23:17 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WIllow!! BenSylarLex
| 23:10 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow eyed Demon
| 23:10 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow eyed Demon
| 23:09 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow eyed Demon
| 23:09 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow eyed Demon
| 23:09 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow eyed Demon
| 23:08 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneSylarLex
| 23:08 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow eyed Demon
| 23:07 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylarYellow eyed Demon
| 23:02 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow Ben Sylar (LOVE HIM!) Yellow eyes demon
| 23:00 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
n/an/aSylar!!Yellow Eyed Demon!
| 22:58 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylerYellow eyed demon (for those interested Yellow Eyes name is Azazel)
| 22:55 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowBenSYLERLex Luthor
| 22:47 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelousSloneSylarYellow eyed demon
| 22:43 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowSloaneMaryannYellow-eyed demon
| 22:42 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark Willow!!!!!!!!!!!!! Ben Dan Scott Trinity Killer
| 22:36 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Sylar (he literally cannot die...Maryanne did.)Yellow Eyed Demon. (I mean, Lex is kind of cruel and stuff...but friggin YED planned out the end of the world / demon apocalypse. For 20+ years. Give the guy some credit.)
| 22:36 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
angelousbensylarlex luthor
| 22:36 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
- dark willow- ben-Maryann-Yellow eyed demon
| 22:35 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Angelus Ben Sylar (my personal favorite) Yellow Eyed Demon
| 22:34 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowSloaneMaryanneYellow Eyed demon
| 22:32 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Angelus Sloane Sylar Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 22:30 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Angelus Sloane Sylar Yellow-Eyed Demon
| 22:30 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Dark WillowBenSylarLex Luthor
| 22:26 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
dark willowsloaneMaryanneLex
| 22:18 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
angelusbensylaryellow-eyed demon
| 22:18 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
sylarlexbendark willow
| 22:14 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneSylarYellow-eyed demon
| 22:02 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Somehow you've got all the crappy villains winning. gg on that.
| 21:56 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneSylarYellow-Eyed Demon C'mon.. with MaryAnn... she died over a trick which means she's a n00b. Sylar is 1. unkillable and 2. has all the power he needs. And her mind tricks wouldnt work with him since his mind would heal too quick for it
| 21:55 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
BenAngelusSyler
| 21:30 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusSloaneMaryAnnYellow Eyed Demon
| 21:19 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AlphaYellow Eyed DemonDark WillowSloane
| 21:16 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
DARK WILLOW! Sloane Lex Luthor MaryAnne DARK WILLOW DARK WILLOW DARK WILLOw, cuz she was evil and hot!
| 21:09 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenMaryannLex Luther
| 21:06 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Trinity KillerAlphaSmokeyDan Scott
| 20:59 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenMaryannLex Luthor
| 20:54 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
AngelusBenSylar (v hard one.. but he wudnt die and maryann finally did)Yellow-eyed demon
| 20:52 EDT, 29 Oct, 2009
Angelus Sloane Sylar Yellow-Eyed Demon

Post Comment

Want to comment on this post? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!