Year in Review: Top Worst Career Moves, Part 1

Do Not Disturb & Carpoolers - Jerry O'Connell

Within 2008, Jerry O'Connell found himself two sitcom flops between Carpoolers that struggled through 13 episodes in which ratings and viewership continued to be bad and get worse, until it was put to rest in March '08. Fortunately, O'Connell got another shot in the new fall season of '08 as he starred in FOX's new sitcom, Do Not Disturb - but unfortunately, this one didn't even struggle through a season, as it quickly became the first new show cancellation of the season after a 3 episode run. Sorry, Jerry. Looks like it's time to return to the big screen... or at least avoid the sitcoms for a while.

Grey's Anatomy - Jeffrey Dean Morgan & T.R. Knight

The tragic romance of intern Izzie Stevens and heart patient Denny Duquette was one of the most riveting storylines to run on Grey's Anatomy, but Jeffrey Dean Morgan, that doesn't mean you should think it's a good idea to come back as a ghost/delusion when the show is floundering. Let dead romances lie in the time they had - why muddy the memories and your career with a pathetic and odd comeback?

And T.R. Knight has not officially left the show yet, but it's pretty official he will be leaving. So what does he think he's going to do post-George, especially leaving before the show has regained its footing? My prediction - career suicide, though I'll be crossing my fingers anyway.

My Own Worst Enemy - Christian Slater

We'll probably be seeing the likes of Christian Slater again, but after starring in the a quickly failed show, returning to the limelight is going to be tricky. It may have been his big primetime TV debut, but it was more like a big TV de-don't. Or something else more clever. I don't doubt we'll get more greatness from Slater in the future, but I do doubt we'll be seeing him starring in a TV show anytime soon.

Cashmere Mafia - Miranda Otto

Miranda Otto's career has included roles in The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (as Eowyn for all you LOTR mega-fans), then later she popped up on the hit USA mini-series, The Starter Wife. Then post-mini-series, Miranda moved on to the new meant-to-be hit, Cashmere Mafia. But alas, here comes her 2008 career mistake - taking that role in a show that flopped after a 7 episode run. While this isn't career suicide for a newer TV actress, it was a pretty big blow that her involvement in the failed Cashmere Mafia meant she was not available to play her previous Starter Wife role when the mini-series was picked up as a successful full series.

Rosie Live - Rosie O'Donnell

I will admit I didn't watch it to be judging it, but maybe that's the point - the promos were as awful as the show, so down went Rosie's variety show immediately after its "big" premiere.

As the Los Angeles Times said of the premiere:

For weeks now, NBC has seduced and tantalized with the promise of a cross between Carol Burnett and "Sonny and Cher." And this is what we get? Rosie in a glitter top having Baldwin speak into her cleavage and making jokes about her weight? Someone get ahold of Tim Conway, stat.

Well, Rosie tried, and the fact is, somehow Rosie will never be gone from our entertainment radar, love her or hate her, but this show was most definitely one of the worst career moves of 2008.

Continue to Part 2



Dec 24, 2008 9:16AM EST

stop hating on slater. lol. MOWE only got better after d cancellation.

Large good to be queen
Dec 24, 2008 7:19PM EST

I love MOWE and will be sad to see it go. It was fresh and new, unlike other clone shows.

Default avatar cat
Dec 26, 2008 1:25AM EST

cashmere mafia should not have been cancelled i loved it!!

Default avatar cat
Dec 31, 2008 3:11PM EST

I so agree tvqueen! Slater did a fabulous job portraying two halves of the same guy. Henry and Edward couldn't be more different. Slater definitely has excellent acting chops. Show will be missed.

Default avatar cat
Jan 31, 2009 5:14AM EST

Carpoolers was hilarious and Jerry was overthetop funny!

Want to comment on this post? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!