Ok holes but not the ones ppl are looking at

Ok I can kinda see the holes in the story but what ppl havent thought of are:


How did Hiro know where to pick up Claire from? also how did he know the exact destination if he's forgotten the times he's been to the rooftop?


Where did Sylar get a can of lighter fluid from (also why didnt he just use his 'nuke' powers to vapourise her?) (also also you cant burn a bosy with that piddly amount of lighter fluid, theres too much water in it it would only char a bit.)

Comments

9 comments

Default avatar cat
×

What's wrong with this comment?

Let us know why you think this comment is inappropriate.

Dec 11, 2008 7:13PM EST

He saw it in the comic book that predicts the future. He just needs to look at a picture of place to telport there. Remember, when the first time he teleported to New York, he just looked at a picture of New York on the bus.

Default avatar cat
×

What's wrong with this comment?

Let us know why you think this comment is inappropriate.

Dec 11, 2008 7:15PM EST

Hiro and Claire were on that exact roof initially. Its where the arrived when they travelled through time. Even tough Hiro couldn't understand english at the time Claire said to 'meet her back there tonight.' Claire went back and I think Hiro kind of just stumbled out there in the middle of the night and happened upon her. And he knew the destination in the comic book because he had been there before he was 10 years old. 16 years in the past he would have been approx. 5-8ish? I don't know his age, I assume its somewhere from 21-24.
And the lighter fluid detail is probably just splitting hairs. They have super powers for gods sake, she would have died from the electrocution anyways, but Sylar hovering over the burning body was much more theatrical.

Default avatar cat
×

What's wrong with this comment?

Let us know why you think this comment is inappropriate.

Dec 11, 2008 7:37PM EST

okay, first of all the comic told him where to go and how to find claire, second sylar doesnt have his nuking power anymore he lost it with the shanti virus, telekinesis is the only power he got back, and as for the lighter fluid i agree with b3astlyz thats just sad that you care that much

Default avatar cat
×

What's wrong with this comment?

Let us know why you think this comment is inappropriate.

Dec 11, 2008 10:44PM EST

There are plenty more holes than that. Firstly Stout23....there is a hole in your theory right there, since when Peter went to the future, Sylar nuked the city after his son died, so he obviously still has that power....which brings us to another hole, in that Peter claims that the future is destroyed because of this Formula, which he basis on Sylar going nuclear...however...Sylar going nuclear has nothing to do with that....he was at home peacefully with his kid...the only reason he went nuclear is because Peter went there to look for him...which brings us to the next hole in the story, which is that Future Peter told Present Peter that he needs to get Sylar's power in order to save the world...so he got the power, but really, unless something drastically happens in a future episode, i don't see why he needed to get Sylar's power in order to save the world. Another hole is that when Peter got Sylar's power, he couldnt' fight the "hunger" and wanted to kill everybody, yet, when Arthur stole the powers from Peter, he didn't have that same hunger. Another hole, is that in the last episode, when Sylar stopped the bullet and froze Arthur, why was he able to use his powers when the Haitian was still there? And if he was able to use his powers, why wouldn't he have wanted to take the Haitians power...

Default avatar cat
×

What's wrong with this comment?

Let us know why you think this comment is inappropriate.

Dec 12, 2008 2:24AM EST

The_Rock most of ur so-called holes in this story aren't holes at all, 4 one u can't base thing off of the future peter sees cause u don't know what happened on the way to that point, so there is no way to tell if sylar has his nuke power or not, thats like saying well future peter has all his powers so he must have his powers now.......wrong, that makes half ur statements wrong that are based off the future,
arthur didn't have the hunger cause 4 one he can take powers by contact, and the man has been around the whole power scene longer than all of them, and the main reason arthur prob didn't have the hunger is cause u have to know how it works, peter has always had sylars power but he never got it to work until he asked sylar to show him
the thing with sylar still having his powers in the last episode, its pretty obvious that the haitain can use his powers in different ways, he can touch u and overload ur mind, nutrualize everyones powers around him, and in the case of arthur he can direct his power all at one person
if peter had shot him sooner sylar would have been affected too

Default avatar cat
×

What's wrong with this comment?

Let us know why you think this comment is inappropriate.

Dec 12, 2008 5:33PM EST

to stout23
how do you know he lost all his powers from the shanti virus apart from telekinesis, that is ridiculous.
yer the haitian was concentrating his power on arthur and was pretty knackered, doubt he could stop sylar's powers easily
he's not like leech from x-men, he can choose who's power to turn off, for example, when him and elle are chasing peter and adam. he doesn't turn off elle's powers as you clearly see she uses them to try to catch them.
and yer aantoine87 is right, peter potentially had sylar's power all along but couldn;t use it until sylar taught him how to use it.
and to the_rock, peter needed sylar's power to understand how to save the world, but the hunger just took over and then he lost his powers so that's down the toilet for the time being
some people spend too much time trying to find holes, they come up with some right stupid stuff

Default avatar cat
×

What's wrong with this comment?

Let us know why you think this comment is inappropriate.

Dec 12, 2008 6:56PM EST

There are not plot holes you morons. Sylar DID lose all his powers from shanti virus, except telekinesis. Future Sylar got radioactivity and precognitive Painting because he absorbed them from Peter while he was in the house. Remember, he has empathy. Thats how he absorbed Elle's electricity power.
For the last time, the Haitian needs to concentrate on blocking powers, he doesn't just automatically block powers. How else would you explain Nathan flying away near him or Peter stopping the taser prongs with telekinesis. Btw, he let them go because he is loyal to Angela. Anyways, he needs to concentrate. He doesn't need to know the power, he just needs to concentrate on blocking it. Remember when he blocked Hiro and Daphne's powers? He did that to protect the half of the formula he was carrying.
Haitian cannot block Sylar's power and had trouble blocking Arthur's because they are very powerful. He can block Peter's because he did so in season 2 when he first met Bob and Elle Bishop, but that might have been because he had just woken up after being shocked, making him weaker. As for Sylar, he cannot block his power, that is why he was able to use telekinesis. Technically, Arthur is dead because we saw the catalyst get destroyed, which would mean his powers as well. Not only that, but the Haitian could have blocked Arthur's healing power AFTER he got shot as Arthut would be weaker with a bullet in his head.
That was the whole fucking point of getting the Haitian to come. Also, glass and a stick are different stories, a bullet is way more powerful. Once the brain is destroyed, like Sylar said, the powers cannot work.
Arthur is very powerful because he has mastered telepathy and absorbed Peter's powers. Also, Arthur does have Sylar's power, but he does NOT know how to fucking use it. Why the hell do you think peter needed Sylar to help get his power. Peter absorbs powers automatically by being around them. He just didn't know how to use it. Most of his powers he is able to figure out on his own, but some require help from the original owner. Dont forget sylar's power is very complex because he is able to take other powers. He needed Sylar to teach him how to use it by understanding the complexity of a watch. SO, Arthur does not have Sylar's power completely. Or at least does not know how to use it.
So stop criticizing this show you loser. Stop watching this TV show if you think it doesn't make sense. And NEWS FLASH, its called SCIENCE FICTION. Its not real, its just a TV show. God you people are the people I hate because you ruin the show just because you're too stupid to figure out things....

Default avatar cat
×

What's wrong with this comment?

Let us know why you think this comment is inappropriate.

Dec 12, 2008 6:57PM EST

BTW, the writers said that sylar lost his powers after Shanti Virus, besides telekinesis. Moron...

Default avatar cat
×

What's wrong with this comment?

Let us know why you think this comment is inappropriate.

Dec 14, 2008 8:49AM EST

surely that right there is a plot hole? the fact that sylar kept telekinesis when it wasnt his original abilitly seems to be a plot hole. though i do agree with you (popularscience100), it is very annoying when everyone tries to find plotholes which arent actually plotholes at all....and they do seem to forget that its not real, mistakes can be made by the writers

Want to comment on this? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!