Discussions for Season 7

American Idol Buzz

American Idol: Did the Right David Win?

EW caught up with both of American Idol 's Davids to chat about On tonight's exciting and extremely, ridiculously drawn out 2-hour American Idol Season 7 finale, we finally got our winner! So now, America (aka SideReel International), we ask you: Did the right David win? In my opinion, absolutely 100%!! But hey, what do I know, I just like David Cook's scruff and that silly thing called talent. What do you think? Should David Archuleta have taken the Idol crown or is David Cook the rightful Season 7 king? Photo courtesy of eonline.com