Brandon Graves, Disappeared in 2010 at the Age of 24 / Sumter, SC A 24-year-old man disappears on a cold night after celebrating homecoming with old friends in Sumter, SC. Cleashindra Hall, Disappeared in 1994 at the Age of 18 / Pine Bluff, AR It’s been almost two decades since 18-year-old Cleashindra Hall has gone missing from the small town of Pine Bluff, AR, after working a late night at her employer’s home. Find Our Missing brought this case to light last season, and is now revisiting this story after witnesses came forward with some shocking testimonies.