The Mentalist Reviews & Ratings

60 minutes

A detective who can mind read--well, not really. However, Detective Patrick Jane (Simon Baker) does posses acute observation skills--skills he honed as a mentalist--and uses them to solve cases for the California Bureau of Investigation.
Cat lurking
Check out rating stats for this show

Show Reviews

93 reviews

Default avatar cat
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

Mar 28, 2016 8:07PM EDT
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

*SPOILER ALERT*
This show is an amazing mixture of crime, mystery, comedy and drama. The concept of Red John was brilliant and it gets the viewer hooked to the show wanting to know how in the hell did he do that? Or how does he know things before Patrick Jane does.
At one point, it felt as though Red John could have been an organization or something, looking at the way he operated and had knowledge of everything. Everything about this show was amazing except one thing... The Reveal.
When Red John was revealed, i doubt i've ever felt as much disappointment about anything else. The way he is dealt with by Patrick; the fact that they didn't tell us how red john operated and how he knew about Patrick's Red John List of Suspects, made me go "omg that was so pathetic. It was much better when we didn't know who Red John was".
If the writers could have done a better ending for Red John, it would have been a literal mind blowing series. But it felt as though they were trying, but couldn't come up with a better Reveal.
But overall would definitely, without a doubt, recommend this show to others.

*SPOILER ALERT*
This show is an amazing mixture of crime, mystery, comedy and drama. The concept of Red John was brilliant and it gets the viewer hooked to the show wanting to know how in the hell did he do that? Or how does he know things before Patrick Jane does.
At one point, it felt as though Red John could have been an organization or something, looking at the way he operated and had knowledge of everything. Everything about this show was amazing except one thing... The Reveal.
When Red John was revealed, i doubt i've ever felt as much disappointment about anything else. The way he is dealt with by Patrick; the fact that they didn't tell us how red john operated and how he knew about Patrick's Red John List of Suspects, made me go "omg that was so pathetic. It was much better when we didn't know who Red John was".
If the writers could have done a better ending for Red John, it would have been a literal mind blowing series. But it felt as though they were trying, but couldn't come up with a better Reveal.
But overall would definitely, without a doubt, recommend this show to others.

Click to reveal spoilers.

Picture?type=square&height=200&width=200
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

Mar 16, 2016 8:21PM EDT
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

Excellent!

Excellent!

Picture?type=square&height=200&width=200
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

by Beenev
Feb 14, 2016 7:33AM EST
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

I am not one for dramas but I loved this show.

I am not one for dramas but I loved this show.

Picture?type=square&height=200&width=200
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

Jan 5, 2016 8:25PM EST
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

I miss this show already! The final season in my opinion was a let down but other than that I enjoyed each episode. Finding out who Red John was became thrilling with each season and kept the show going nicely. I would definitely recommend.

I miss this show already! The final season in my opinion was a let down but other than that I enjoyed each episode. Finding out who Red John was became thrilling with each season and kept the show going nicely. I would definitely recommend.

Large 1407004262 barbed wire
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

Dec 28, 2015 5:35PM EST
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

Watched the first season sort of bailed in the second. The show was a standard CBS procedural so it was mediocre.

Watched the first season sort of bailed in the second. The show was a standard CBS procedural so it was mediocre.

Picture?type=square&height=200&width=200
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

Dec 17, 2015 12:19AM EST
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

This was an excellent show at it's prime...that was before Red John was caught and killed. The show really should have ended there - on a fantastic high, instead, we were treated to a below par follow-up season, that result in the unlikely love story that was never a will they, won't there. Jane and Lisbon did not have any chemistry until it was force upon us, in many uncomfortable scenes until we finally accepted it. Much like Lost and Heroes, it started off with a bang but ended - just ended.

This was an excellent show at it's prime...that was before Red John was caught and killed. The show really should have ended there - on a fantastic high, instead, we were treated to a below par follow-up season, that result in the unlikely love story that was never a will they, won't there. Jane and Lisbon did not have any chemistry until it was force upon us, in many uncomfortable scenes until we finally accepted it. Much like Lost and Heroes, it started off with a bang but ended - just ended.

Picture?type=square&height=200&width=200
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

by rbruski
Dec 5, 2015 12:15PM EST
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

Such a great show. It's just another crime drama but they've put a cool spin on it with a mentalist. You really start to like Patrick Jane as the seasons go on. But as soon as Red John is caught the plot kind of goes downhill.

Such a great show. It's just another crime drama but they've put a cool spin on it with a mentalist. You really start to like Patrick Jane as the seasons go on. But as soon as Red John is caught the plot kind of goes downhill.

Picture?type=square&height=200&width=200
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

Nov 6, 2015 9:24AM EST
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

The last season was weird. And the whole Red John thing was frequently confusing, even when binge watching the show.

The last season was weird. And the whole Red John thing was frequently confusing, even when binge watching the show.

Picture?type=square&height=200&width=200
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

Oct 29, 2015 4:46PM EDT
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

For anyone who thinks this is close to Psych...you're dead wrong. While both shows take a similar premise, they're so different in many ways. This show does have a man with the ability to spot minute details, but he does so much more, he plays mind games with people, reads their emotions and sets elaborate traps to catch them. Many compare him to Shawn Spencer of Psych, but I would rather compare him to Sherlock Holmes, except more tortured. The pilot obviously takes on a more serious approach than Psych and the dynamics of the show go from cute and funny to deeply disturbing in seconds.

It takes your one crime per episode procedural drama with a gifted detective and takes it one step further. Patrick Jane is more self effacing, gets into trouble and is a known fraud. But he isn't mean or intentionally rubs people the wrong way like House(also based on Holmes) or Spencer. He is very soothing, warm, instills trust and seems to get along with people pretty well, from the guy who did it to his team. At the same time, he does like to flex his intellect and power over people and loves to play games to get answers (and yet, so charming when he does so). So it's kind of disarming when you begin to see there are some serious issues with this character, he doesn't sleep, doesn't believe in life after death (and is happy that way), and is actually anti-social with the group. There are further reasons as to his psychosis that won't be discussed. Behind those warm baby blues, warm smile and calming presence, there is a man being crushed to death by very weighty issues.

Patrick Jane is a fantastic character, he's obviously brilliant, but a little distant and isn't fond of working with others. As a former faux psychic he seems pretty ready to disable believers. And of course, Simon Baker is a brilliant actor and is the reason I tuned in (I admit I too feared this was a Psych ripoff) and he brings so much depth to this character. When he plays his mind games he always brings a sense of "I know more than you and there is nothing you can do about it." type of amusement and when Red John or death apparates in conversation you see a distant look in his eyes that conveys more than what he actually saying (the psychiatry appointment in the pilot was incredible). He really plays off the layers of Patrick Jane well, pulling some back and when we get a true glimpse, the layers fall back in place. And credit goes to the set-up of Red John as his "nemesis" through a copy cat. He and Jane have a very tense meet up awaiting them, but I can wait for that just to experience the chase and the unraveling history between these two.

Another credit would go to the incredible Robin Tunney (of The Craft and Empire Records) who was reason number two for watching the pilot. She has had very little to work with in the first two episodes (but her role grew from 1 to 2 so I have faith), but she plays the hard nosed detective with a little more prudishness and distance than I would have expected. How much she knows about Jane and how far they go back is a mystery to me and their dynamic is interesting. She doesn't fall into stereotype and has retained a beguiling sense of mystery. I also appreciate the lack of clichéd moments "fraught with sexual tension" between Lisbon and Jane.

And I'd also like to credit Tim Kang- a lovely surprise and I enjoyed his character who really doesn't give a crap about hurting people's feelings or stepping on toes, he just wants to solve the case. Love it and kudos.

My only complaint would be explained in the two above paragraphs briefly. I love Cho and Lisbon and hope to get see more of the team (Van Pelt and Rigsby are really cute as well), but I understand this is called "The Mentalist" and there is still time to slowly introduce Jane's history with the team and more in depth coverage of these characters. I've only seen two episodes and I think what I anticipate will come into fruition.

Overall, this show is well written, well acted, and beautifully shot. I for one have set up a season recording on my DVR and cannot wait for the next episode, yes you can consider me a fan and I hope you head over to CBS.com and give this show a chance. I wish I had more stars to give.

For anyone who thinks this is close to Psych...you're dead wrong. While both shows take a similar premise, they're so different in many ways. This show does have a man with the ability to spot minute details, but he does so much more, he plays mind games with people, reads their emotions and sets elaborate traps to catch them. Many compare him to Shawn Spencer of Psych, but I would rather compare him to Sherlock Holmes, except more tortured. The pilot obviously takes on a more serious approach than Psych and the dynamics of the show go from cute and funny to deeply disturbing in seconds.

It takes your one crime per episode procedural drama with a gifted detective and takes it one step further. Patrick Jane is more self effacing, gets into trouble and is a known fraud. But he isn't mean or intentionally rubs people the wrong way like House(also based on Holmes) or Spencer. He is very soothing, warm, instills trust and seems to get along with people pretty well, from the guy who did it to his team. At the same time, he does like to flex his intellect and power over people and loves to play games to get answers (and yet, so charming when he does so). So it's kind of disarming when you begin to see there are some serious issues with this character, he doesn't sleep, doesn't believe in life after death (and is happy that way), and is actually anti-social with the group. There are further reasons as to his psychosis that won't be discussed. Behind those warm baby blues, warm smile and calming presence, there is a man being crushed to death by very weighty issues.

Patrick Jane is a fantastic character, he's obviously brilliant, but a little distant and isn't fond of working with others. As a former faux psychic he seems pretty ready to disable believers. And of course, Simon Baker is a brilliant actor and is the reason I tuned in (I admit I too feared this was a Psych ripoff) and he brings so much depth to this character. When he plays his mind games he always brings a sense of "I know more than you and there is nothing you can do about it." type of amusement and when Red John or death apparates in conversation you see a distant look in his eyes that conveys more than what he actually saying (the psychiatry appointment in the pilot was incredible). He really plays off the layers of Patrick Jane well, pulling some back and when we get a true glimpse, the layers fall back in place. And credit goes to the set-up of Red John as his "nemesis" through a copy cat. He and Jane have a very tense meet up awaiting them, but I can wait for that just to experience the chase and the unraveling history between these two.

Another credit would go to the incredible Robin Tunney (of The Craft and Empire Records) who was reason number two for watching the pilot. She has had very little to work with in the first two episodes (but her role grew from 1 to 2 so I have faith), but she plays the hard nosed detective with a little more prudishness and distance than I would have expected. How much she knows about Jane and how far they go back is a mystery to me and their dynamic is interesting. She doesn't fall into stereotype and has retained a beguiling sense of mystery. I also appreciate the lack of clichéd moments "fraught with sexual tension" between Lisbon and Jane.

And I'd also like to credit Tim Kang- a lovely surprise and I enjoyed his character who really doesn't give a crap about hurting people's feelings or stepping on toes, he just wants to solve the case. Love it and kudos.

My only complaint would be explained in the two above paragraphs briefly. I love Cho and Lisbon and hope to get see more of the team (Van Pelt and Rigsby are really cute as well), but I understand this is called "The Mentalist" and there is still time to slowly introduce Jane's history with the team and more in depth coverage of these characters. I've only seen two episodes and I think what I anticipate will come into fruition.

Overall, this show is well written, well acted, and beautifully shot. I for one have set up a season recording on my DVR and cannot wait for the next episode, yes you can consider me a fan and I hope you head over to CBS.com and give this show a chance. I wish I had more stars to give.

Large charlie mazas
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

Oct 17, 2015 8:46AM EDT
0
×

What's wrong with this review?

Let us know why you think this review is inappropriate.

The best thing about this show is Jane's character. The comments, the jokes, the conversations are very good and boosts the entertainment level of the Mentalist. There are many shows on similar topic, yet none of them gave me this much pleasure.

The best thing about this show is Jane's character. The comments, the jokes, the conversations are very good and boosts the entertainment level of the Mentalist. There are many shows on similar topic, yet none of them gave me this much pleasure.