Stacy and Clinton catch up with 8 past candidates and see if they kept up with their new looks or slipped back into their patterns of bad taste. Invited to the reunion are: Marcy Feinstone, Belinda Hill, Melanie LaPatton, Michaela Krenks, Cristina Hernandez, Susan Crandall, Jeannie "Gogoboots", and Nancy Herton, who shocks the team by announcing she lost 30 pounds since her appearance and now can't fit into the new clothes! Stacy and Clinton agree to give Nancy a "mini-makeover" of $1000 so she can buy a new outfit for an upcoming special event with her family. Nick and Carmindy surprise Michaela by offering to fix her hair and makeup, which she hated the first time out.