Sunnydale is silenced when mysterious entities from a children's tale, known as “The Gentlemen,” steal everyone's voices in order to harvest organs from the populace. Despite being unable to hear the silent cries of those in trouble, Buffy must stop the slaughter by finding alternate ways to communicate with Giles about the dangerous beings. Anya: Emma Caulfield. Riley: Marc Blucas. Maggie: Lindsay Crouse. Giles: Anthony Stewart Head. Buffy: Sarah Michelle Gellar.