In 1995, Lisa Manderach and her daughter Devon left their Pennsylvania home to go shopping, but didn't return home at the expected time. Lisa's husband Jimmy called police in a panic to report their disappearance and he directed them to a nearby shopping center. Later that day, Devon's body was found dumped off of a roadside, but there was no sign of Lisa. Looking further into the store Lisa had said she was going to, police shift their focus to store employee Caleb Fairley.