Part 1. Photos left in Tony's cab by Herve Villechaize of "Fantasy Island" prompt the cabbies to indulge in their own fantasies. Herve Villechaize, Eric Sevareid: Themselves. Alex: Judd Hirsch. Tony: Tony Danza. Latka: Andy Kaufman. Bobby: Jeff Conaway. Jim: Christopher Lloyd. Elaine: Marilu Henner. Louie: Danny De Vito. First Customer: Warren Munson. Second Customer: Carl Lumbly.