Dear John - Review


Novelist Nicholas Sparks' formula of life-altering love -- invariably faced with some grand, operatic impediment -- receives the youth-edition treatment in "Dear John," an almost painfully earnest romance that throws the Sept. 11 terror attacks between its Romeo and Juliet. Mostly, the movie provides ample opportunity to admire Channing Tatum's broad shoulders and Amanda Seyfried's incandescent smile, but the narrative device that keeps them connected while geographically apart doesn't work especially well onscreen. The result amounts to a handsome Lifetime movie that could do some modest business before taking its place on the lower shelves of the Sparks bibliography.


Other Sparks adaptations have offered the somewhat rare allure of seeing characters experience transformative love ("Nights in Rodanthe," "Message in a Bottle") in middle age, after they've experienced pain and disappointments. Here, Special Forces soldier John (Tatum) meets fresh-faced student Savannah (Seyfried) on spring break, triggering a whirlwind affair ("Two weeks together. That's all it took," she writes him) and the inevitable "uh-oh" effect -- inasmuch as he talks about leaving the service in a year's time to be with her, but the period is the spring of 2001.


As a consequence, the fall of the World Trade Center towers becomes the unanticipated sticking point to John and Savannah's plans, as the two remain in contact via a series of letters, which are generally read to accompaniment from gauzy musical montages. While director Lasse Hallstrom and writer Jamie Linden do what they can to make these sequences pop, the pic takes on a drowsy quality during its extended midsection from which it never fully recovers.


To Read More Click Here

Comments

1 comment

Default avatar cat
×

What's wrong with this comment?

Let us know why you think this comment is inappropriate.

Feb 11, 2010 11:32AM EST

Watch all the latest movies online for FREE

Want to comment on this? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!