'American Idol' Top 8: Casey Abrams, James Durbin go outside the box, but rock it


After the "American Idol" travesty that was Pia Toscano getting sent home last week, the Top 6 men and the two girls America has let tag along are singing songs from the movies. The show starts off with a dramatic re-living of the Pia debacle, complete with People's Most Beautiful Person Jennifer Lopez in tears. Oh, the humanity.So let's see how the cinema songs treated the "American Idol" contestants. Here are the Top 8 Idols, from best to worst:1. Casey Abrams, "Nature Boy," Nat King Cole, "The Boy With Green Hair"Casey's rockin' the upright bass and old-timey microphone. This is a very weird choice for this show - at least do the "Moulin Rouge" version. Casey is really chewing his words and notes, it's atonal and strange. It's like Caesy is jamming on stage at a jazz club. $10 will get you $20 Simon would call this "self-indulgent." The viewers will not know what to...



Want to comment on this? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!