American Idol Recap: James Blew Jennifer Lopez Away, but Who Made Steven Tyler "Hear God"?

There are only six left on American Idol.

Now is the time when the judges start to—maybe not in so many words—give up on certain contestants, saying things like, "I hope you get to stick around," "You deserve to be here" and other half-hearted words of encouragement.

Tonight, the reigning sextet took on classic tunes by Carole King. Who do you think the judges still believe in?

Barring a major upset, or a particularly bad Haley Reinhart performance, Jacob Lusk is going home tomorrow—and, sadly, we knew that before he sang. Our thoughts were confirmed afterward, when Randy Jackson told him, ahem, "Hopefully America will give you some votes and you'll stick around." Read More...


Want to comment on this? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!