Emma starts to remember details about her birth mother after a late-night meeting with Ethan. The twins discover they’ve been having identical nightmares for years, and Sutton wants answers about Emma’s early life. The clues from Emma help Sutton find their birth mother’s old house, an discovery which puts Sutton at great risk. Meanwhile, Emma wants to get Ethan cleared of suspicion and turns to Ted. Sutton’s adoptive father begins to act secretive and guilty.