The X Factor Top 17 Review: It's Just Drew

I complained last week that The X Factor had done very little to differentiate itself from American Idol up until this point.  Well that changed with the first live show, as X Factor showcased something Idol has yet to in ten seasons...an utter and extensive lack of talent.

Sure there were a few bright spots in the Top 17, most of which came out of the girls category, but it was quite obvious that while searching for the artist with the x factor these judges forgot to also look for good singers.

Before we move on to the individual performances let me first recognize what the judges have decided to do for criticism of the contestants they didn't like.  Because L.A., Paula and Nicole can't hate on these singers, they have chosen to just trash on whatever judge is mentoring that performer, and then say something nice to the contestant immediately afterwards.  It's cowardly, it doesn't help the people on stage to hear such hypocritical analysis, and most importantly it takes up more of my time. Read More...


http://www.tvfanatic.com/2011/10/the-x-factor-top-17-review-its-just-drew/

Comments

Want to comment on this? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!