A shocking crime! A funny convolution! Welcome to HIMYM's 2010 Zoo or False!
Marshal gets mugged in a park. Who mugged him? Barney comes up with a wrenched story making it sound like it was 1947. When Marshal tells Lily about being mugged by a naked man, she decides to get a gun. Ha! As if that's a surprise. Bestfriend Robin definitely had a huge say on this, didn't she? And could you imagine Robin and Lily with guns? Girls Gone Wild Canadian New York style- Robin, the hot headed 54 pistol carrier, and Lily, a shotgun??? LOL. just saying.
So Marshal ends up trying to fabricate the story to his advantage of stopping Lily. It seems Ted and Barney help him lie as you would expect Marshal to fail gravely when it is with Lily.
Barney : Is he telling the truth?
" Ted quips , "I wouldn't know, he smells good."
How I Met Your Mother airs Monday, April 12 (8:00-8:30 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network starring Josh Radnor as Ted, Jason Segel as Marshal, Cobie Smulders as Robin, Neil Patrick Harris as Barney, and Alyson Hannigan as Lily.