This week on Pretty Little Liars, Spencer finally finds out Toby has been on the 'A' Team this whole time. It's heartbreaking and actress Troian Bellisario nails it just like you would expect. Poor Spencer, who is usually the first to suspect everyone, certainly didn't expect to get played like she did.
"Tell me there's more to the story," she cries while pounding on Toby's door later that night. It's what many fans of the couple (affectionately called Spoby) were certainly hoping for. Maybe Toby was a double agent, using his abs for great justice and finding out intel on the inside?
But that was always just a pipe dream. Just like we the audience couldn't initially accept kindhearted Toby as a hoodie-wearing creep about town, Spencer can't initially accept what she knows to be true.