'American Idol' Top 10 men: The Charlie Askew experiment needs to end

So, after a pretty strong night from the ladies on "American Idol" Tuesday (March 5), we hope you've got some stiff drinks at hand to help you get through this gauntlet of awful. Sorry, do we sound bitter? It's because we are. Most of these guys have been atrocious so far.1. Elijah Liu, "Stay," RihannaInteresting song choice, but he definitely has the sweet tenor to pull it off. This is actually pretty nice. There are a few bum notes here and there, but he has such a pretty tone. It's not blowing our wig off, but it wasn't bad. We just wish he had done a little more with it. The song didn't really go anywhere. More oomph, more personality would've been good.Urban is right that the song suited his voice -- it really did. Nicki manages not to be too gross towards this young man, then comments on his marketability, which is totally right....



Want to comment on this? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!