And the Killer is.....

Spoiler alert!!!

do not read this if you haven't seen episode 9 (seep) it will ruin it for you





so from the beginning, I have suspected Sheriff Mills, and as the episodes go on He seems like the likely suspect, what if Wakefield never was a murderer? what if it was the sheriff all the while? this would make sense, the scene of abby running away and then her dad appears beside her at the tree? how did he get there so fast? and how did he find it without her calling him? or maybe she called him and Im sorely mistaken, so what are your thoughts? is the sheriff another red herring? or is he the killer?

my other suspects are

Booth (see 10 little Indians for reference as to why) ie the killer ended up being someone that was already dead (that killed hisself)

Jimmy and Henry are also up there on the suspect list, but i really don't want it to be Jimmy as I have fallen in love with the character.

and then there is the wedding planner she also is suspect.....

but then this series may be the first unpredictable series Ive ever watched...I'd be stoked if they surprise me

Anyways I just wanted some disscussion around this, see if Im right or wrong, do you all agree or disagree with me???



Default avatar cat
Jun 12, 2009 9:41PM EDT

I was kinda confused about the sherriff bit. Came out of the blue for me. If he is the killer who set fire to Cole's cabin and tried to kill him? He could have been using Madison to keep everyone on the Island (he may have suspected one and needed them to stay to apprehend the killer? I'm just speculating).
Wedding planner is hella suspicious.
Agreed about Booth. He and Beth are the only ones whose bodies haven't been recovered or thoroughly examined yet - and thus the only ones who could have faked it. I lean more towards Beth who I think is a little dodgy.
Lovveee Jimmy and Henry. I'd hate for it to be either one of them. I'm have to say I don't think it is them. It would be so predictable.

Default avatar cat
Jun 14, 2009 8:45AM EDT

The sheriff is definitely a red herring, they wouldn't ruin the 'cluedo' theme thats going on.

Jimmy and Henry as i've said from the beginning, must be the killers,definitely Jimmy, even if he's my favorite character.

Default avatar cat
Jun 14, 2009 10:34AM EDT

Is it possible that Wakefield's child that he had with Abby's mom was not Abby? That it is another one of the guest that want revenge for their father? Throughout the series there has been no mention of Jimmy's parents? I wonder if Jimmy is Wakefields and Abby's mom's child and he wants Abby. They did say it was all about Abby.

Default avatar cat
Jun 14, 2009 12:44PM EDT

They recovered Beth's body, chopped to pieces. It's definitely not here.
Jimmy was on the island and not on the boat when "cousin Ben" was set up to die. Therefore, he could not have been the killer, unless he has an accomplice.

Default avatar cat
Jun 14, 2009 1:31PM EDT

I don't think it's the sheriff. He's being framed. I agree it's gotta be Henry. I got a suggestion, but I put it up before I read this.
Please check it out: The Ultimate Plot Revealed.

Default avatar cat
Jun 14, 2009 4:33PM EDT

Sammyblade, your theory would mean Abby is sleeping with her brother (as Abby and Jimmy would have the same mother). I hope to God they don't pull it in that direction. yuck.But you do have a point Wakefield's child isn't necessarily jimmy.But they did say its all about Abby, assuming they meant her being the last one connected to wakefield (i.e his daughter)

Default avatar cat
Jun 17, 2009 2:23PM EDT

it cant be booth he was burried and when cal went ot check on him the ground wasnt unturned

Default avatar cat
Jun 18, 2009 1:34AM EDT

doesn't mean he didn't put the ground back to the way it was

Default avatar cat
Jun 18, 2009 9:36AM EDT

Henry is also a very obvious suspect, but I find him too obvious. the more time Ive had to think it over the more I think that the sheriff is just another red herring, I agree that abby may not be wakefields child, it could be one of the other 25 people, or sorry 12, since 13 are dead.I find it strange that henry wanted to get married on the 7th anniversary of the killings on the island, morbid much?although you know what would come just absoulutely out of no whereTrish, I would truely be shocked if she was the killer, but wouldnt that be cool, her being like haha in your face I never wanted to get married I just wanted to kill you all!!!Ok its definitely wayyy to early for me to be discussing

Want to comment on this post? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!