Supernatural 4.2: "Are You There, God? It's Me, Dean Winchester"

I have to give the writers credit once again for sticking with their guns. Now that angels of the Lord are a part of the mythos, the characters discuss them at length and try to work out their place in the order of things. It's the same discussion that the fans have had since the revelation at the end of the premiere, and the explanations fit without too much trouble.

In essence, the hunters have never heard of angelic intervention because, quite simply, there hasn't been any. According to Casstiel, the angels aren't deployed until the situation gets apocalyptic and there's a possibility that Lucifer might actually be released. Lilith and her demonic followers are making just such a move, opening a total of 66 seals to accomplish the task.

None of the action quite fits with the Book of Revelation, but it's enough to communicate how the war has escalated. It might also begin to explain why Dean was delivered out of Hell to do God's work. Regardless of the circumstances, the Brothers Winchester unleashed the demons on Earth at the end of the second season. That included Lilith, who has started this latest mess and forced the angels to war. Whether or not Azazel had this in mind from the start, Sam and Dean bear some responsibility to make things right. This was the interpretation that Gordon and others followed early in the third season.

I still think this will involve each brother making use of their respective resources. The easiest way to undercut Lilith would be for Sam to assume his mantle as Antichrist Superstar. He still has Ruby and her training in his back pocket. And I still think Dean has untapped abilities as well, perhaps as a side effect of his relationship with Casstiel. That said, if this is becoming a truly cosmic battle between God and Lucifer, then all bets are off the table.

Taking the wide view, while Dean's questions touch on the pulse of so many in the world, especially in tough times, it makes sense for God to hold back. For one thing, if the presence of an angel can do the kind of damage seen in the premiere, God's direct intervention would be even more powerful. Besides, it's a question of scale. The hunters were fighting former humans converted into demons. When the bigger demons came out and Lilith went after the seals, that represented an escalation: the big guns had to come out to match the forces of darkness. As the Book of Revelation makes clear, the headliners don't throw down until the endgame.

None of which would matter if it didn't come down to what "Supernatural" does best: character. Dean is still struggling with his long-standing atheism, and we're beginning to see some cracks in his hyper-defensive stance. At this point, with the issues surrounding the CW, the writers can afford to take chances and explore matters of faith in more depth. Dean is usually the less emotive brother, so this is a real opportunity.

Both brothers (and Bobby, for that matter) get to show their deep sorrow and horror for the consequences of their chosen profession. That said, I think they're taking on too much responsibility on their own shoulders. All of those deaths were caused by the demons and monsters that the Winchesters and Bobby sought to kill. The objective truth is that there would be a lot more death and suffering had the hunters never acted in the first place.

But I also believe that it is that very human quality of assuming guilt that keeps the Brothers Winchester grounded. They've always taken responsibility for things out of their control. It also continues to drive them to stop more from happening. We've seen others (like Gordon, for example) who have lost perspective. It's hard to watch Sam and Dean take the accusations of their "victims", but they wouldn't be our heroes if they didn't.



Default avatar cat
Sep 26, 2008 10:33PM EDT

Hats off to you....The best review for episode 2

Default avatar cat
Sep 27, 2008 10:42AM EDT

this series has gone to my top spot on my list... beating Buffy(saying that cos I'm a very very big Buffy supporter) in terms of depth of character and good writing...and damn the show is getting philosophical....which i so adore so much...eric has done an amazing job with character development!!!!!!! damn i am in love with good television

Default avatar cat
Sep 28, 2008 2:26AM EDT

Are we ever gonna SEE HOW Dean was "draged" as the angel said it out of hell ??
Thats wat I would love to see..I dont think it's easy to drag a condemned soul out of hell at least not for an angel (if it was god ok but ..... it's not)
when's the next ep airing??

Default avatar cat
Sep 28, 2008 5:16AM EDT

the next episode airs in America on thursday 2nd October. However, it prob wont be on this site till the day after :)
I'd like to see how they pulled Dean out of Hell but i'm kinda glad hes nt there anymore! I think the casting of Castiel is perfect as well the actors doing a great job. I liked the scene in the kitchen between him and Dean and he's like give me some respect!
I'm curious as to where they are going with God having a mission for Dean it's a brillient story line and i guess the logical next step for the series.

Default avatar cat
Sep 30, 2008 4:36PM EDT

Great review.I feel that Kripke and the writers are taking the series in the appropriate direction, as usual. However, Supernatural has always been slated for five seasons. I can't help but wonder what will happen from now until it's over. Yes, the brothers have secrets from each other. But once that's exposed, what can be done? They've both already died.It seems as though the Winchesters will be pitted against one another...Sam as the Antichrist, Dean as some angelic warrior. But I can imagine Sam being evil about as easily as I can imagine Bobby making out with Dean (shudder...).Hmm...we're treading on uneasy ground here.The show is fantastic as of yet. I just hope it can maintain that, and that the characters remain faithful to their personalities, and not to what the plot determines.

Default avatar cat
Oct 8, 2008 1:58PM EDT

I don't know why people find it difficult to envision Sam turning evil. I don't find it that hard to picture. He's been growing steadily darker as time goes by, especially in 3rd season. Killing the crossroads demon? Wanting to steal Doc Benton's formula? Sure, his motivation is pure, but he's definitely treading some darker water. And Dean told him, in No Rest for the Wicked, the path to hell is paved with good intentions. I think he's been acting particularly dark in this season. Going against Dean's dying wish, keeping some pretty big secrets -just the smoothness of his lies is creepy. And Ruby was in her panties in his hotel room. Hmm. Suspicious. I also think he's showing signs of being addicted to his powers. Lazarus Rising- he left Dean alone to go out and kill those demons even though Dean wanted him to focus on finding out what dragged him out of hell. It wasn't necessary and the smirk he gave Ruby when she praised how good he was getting? I really think he's getting a bit puffed up in regards to his powers. Pride is the root of all sin, right? ;D And again in 4x03, he left Dean alone to go hunting with Ruby. I think he'll turn evil without even realizing it. A lot of villains think that what they're doing is right. Again the idea of the road to hell being paved with good intentions- I think that's Sam in a nutshell.

Want to comment on this post? First, you must log in to your SideReel account!