Angel is alone in a conference room, impatient because heâs called a meeting and no one else is there. Spike enters with a briefcase, wanting to take part in his first meeting with the group. He and Angel discuss the impending apocalypse and Angel says that the Senior Partners are planning something. He doesnât want to sit around and wait for them to do something, so Spike suggests finding a link to them. The two head to Eveâs apartment, but she wonât help them. Eve berates Angel for letting the Senior Partners take Lindsey. Angel notes that Eve is keeping herself hidden from the Senior Partners because she knows that if they find out where she is, theyâll take her. The building starts to shake, Eve blames Angel, thinking he told the Senior Partners. He didn't. All the protective symbols in the apartment dissolve, then Eve changes her mind. She says that sheâll tell him anything he wants to know if he takes her with him. As a man in a suit (Adam Baldwin) arrives, Angel, Spike, and Eve make their escape.
Angel and Spike take Eve to the firm, then update Gunn and ask if he has jurisdiction to protect Eve. Gunn is reluctant, but finally says Angel, as CEO of Wolfram & Hart, can invoke an order to protect Eve. In his apartment, Wesley has a dream about Fred. When he wakes up, Illyria is with him. They both confess they donât like the world much and she wonders why heâs still in it. Back at the firm, Eve reveals that she's an immortal "child of the Senior Partners, created to do their bidding,â but is only on a need-to-know basis with them. Lindsey could have given them more info, but the Senior Partners imprisoned him to a hell dimension.
Lorne says Eve was being sincere when he read her - âNo one can fake it through 'The PiÃ±a Colada Song', not once the chorus kicks in.â Angel wants to know what Lindsey knows about the Senior Partners, but Spike points out that theyâll have a hard time figuring out which hell dimension Lindsey is in. Gunn arrives, having shed his lawyer look for his old street-based appearance, and announces that he knows. Lindsey, it turns out, is living with a beautiful wife and child in the Senior Partnersâ idea of Hell: suburbia. He goes out to get the morning paper, he picks up his sonâs skateboard, he helps his son with his homework. His wife tells him that the oven light went out and she needs him to go to the basement to get a new bulb. Lindsey reluctantly heads downstairs, scared of something. Angel, Spike, and Gunn head to the garage and get in a Camaro that drives itself, prompting Spike to think of KITT from Knight Rider. Gunn tells them when they arrive, they have to find the Wrath, which they have to go through to get back to Wolfram & Hart.
After the group tells Lindsey the truth of who he is, he tells them to leave (after believing their story to be a neighbor-inspired joke). Angel breaks the spell Lindsey is under by removing his necklace; as they try to leave, Lindsey's wife arrives and opens fire with an uzi. They make a run for the Camaro, but its gone. An ice cream truck pulls up and its driver shoots at them, soon joined by a mailman. Spike, Gunn, and Lindsey run back to the house. Lindseyâs son joins in the gunfight as Gunn tries to figure out where the Wrath is. He suggests trying to get out through the basement, but Lindsey refuses.
Meanwhile, at Wolfram & Hart, Eve worries that the Senior Partners wonât honor the CEO-protection arrangement. Lorne assures Eve that no one can get into the building, but right-on-cue, the building alarm sounds and the man in the suit arrives, kills a guard, and heads for Angelâs office.
Returning to the hell dimension, the team discovers that the basement is a torture chamber. Spike finds a pile of hearts, which Lindsey says are his - which were carved out by the Wrath, after inflicting torture. Angel finds a huge flaming furnace and thinks it might be the Wrath. Lindsey notes that âheâ is coming, and the guys see a demon approaching. After Spike and Angel fight the Wrath, Gunn sees they are losing badly. So he puts on Lindseyâs necklace, saying, âIf one leaves, one has to stay. A void is impossible.â Angel realizes that Gunn came along because he knew about this and wanted to atone for Fredâs death. Gunn argues with Angel and Spike; and then tells them they must leave before he forgets as the door will close. Angel, Spike and Lindsey head through the furnace, and once the gate closes, Gunn's memory is erased and he believes that he is "where I belong". "Honey, what are you doing down there?" the wife asks. "I don't know, I must be losing my mind," replies the husband (Gunn).
At the Wolfram & Hart offices, Harmony tries to kill the guy in the suit by breaking his neck, but the man easily throws Harmony off. Eve and Lorne dash for the elevator, and the door closes just in time. Lorne and Eve arrive in Angelâs car garage and try to drive off, but the portal opens above them and Angel, Spike, and Lindsey land on the car. Eve is thrilled to see Lindsey. Lorne starts to warn Angel about the guy in the suit, but he realizes that Gunn hasnât returned. Angel tells him that they left him behind, despite their past agreement to never leave someone behind. The man in the suit arrives, pulls out Eve's contract, and has her sign it. He introduces himself as Marcus Hamilton, their new liaison to the Senior Partners. Eve has just signed over her immortality and her duties to him. Hamilton tells Angel that the Senior Partners are 100% behind him, and welcomes Spike to the team.
In Angelâs apartment, Lorne pulls bullets out of Spike (quipping that he doesn't have the same soft touch as "Fredikins") as Lindsey and Eve cuddle, happy to be back together. Angel tells Lindsey he will go into the holding facilities of Wolfram & Hart, after he tells Angel and the group what he knows about the Senior Partners' plans. Lindsey talks about Earth being Hell which is how Wolfram & Hart works and thrives. Angel says heâs already heard that speech three years ago from Holland Manners. âDid you ever prove him wrong?â Lindsey asks. He tells Angel the apocalypse has been around them even before Angel and his friends came to work at Wolfram & Hart, and Angel hasnât seen it. âHeroes donât accept the world the way it is,â Lindsey says. âHeroes fight.â Angel realizes everything theyâve been doing at Wolfram & Hart has been a distraction by the Senior Partners to keep them from looking under the surface and seeing whatâs been happening all around them. âThe warâs already here, Angel,â Lindsey tells him. âAnd youâre already two soldiers down.â Meanwhile, in the suburbia dimension, Gunn helps his son with his homework, discussing the layers of the Earth. His wife sends him to the basement for an oven bulb, but heâs reluctant to go.