An enraptured audience watches a play in a stone amphitheatre. The main characters are called B'Elanna Torres and Harry Kim, and they are on an adventure seeking dilithium when they are in a shipwreck. Harry gets out in an escape pod but B'Elanna crashes and is injured. Kelis the Poet, the playwright, steps in and narrates his rescue of B'Elanna. The audience is pleased by this interesting and creative plot twist.
Afterwards, Kelis is congratulated by his wealthy patron, who demands to see another play about these Voyager adventures. He wants it done in one week. Desperate for a new story, Kelis travels to the source of his inspiration.
The wreckage of the Delta Flyer sits on a mountainside outside the village. Kelis creeps in and finds B'Elanna where he left her, tied up and with one of her arms covered with bloody slashes. Well-meaning Kelis has been bleeding her, trying to treat the fever that has kept her incapacitated for the eight days since the crash. She has now recovered enough to fight back, so she directs him to heal her cuts with a dermal regenerator. When the cuts disappear, he is convinced she is really an "Eternal". From his exploration of the computer and B'Elanna's logs he knows that her fellow gods await her on a great ship called Voyager.
Despite her being an Eternal, Kelis is not afraid to negotiate with her. B'Elanna promises to tell him more stories he can use for his plays if he unties her. When he does, she grabs a phaser and chases him off. As she works to get the Flyer running again, the bold playwright returns with food for her, asking to hear stories in return for it. She's more interested in getting off the planet so she demands he bring her some dilithium. It is a common mineral in the area, and he knows where to get it, but he'll have to risk trespassing on his patron's property to harvest it. He decides it's worth it to hear more tales about Voyager.
Meanwhile, the Voyager crew has just spent over a week searching for their lost crewmates. Janeway reluctantly calls off the search for B'Elanna and Harry. Tom Paris is especially distraught, not wanting to accept the loss of his girlfriend and his best buddy.
Kelis works on his play. This one will feature more of the crew, but he is having trouble understanding the motivations of these strange characters. He pesters B'Elanna for more information about them, and the two work out more arrangements: he brings her resources and she tells him about her crewmates.
Kelis has more reason to write a great play when his patron begins fighting with his enemy. If a war were to break out, B'Elanna would be discovered and captured, so she agrees to go back to the amphitheatre with Kelis. She sees how the play is progressing, and is nauseated by all the romance. She insists there are more inspirational stories to tell. When he hears about the Borg and Janeway's Starfleet pacifism, he decides to write a tale of peace that will send a message to his patron while entertaining him.
Finally, Harry Kim shows up, after having walked 200 kilometers from his crashed escape pod. He has an emergency transmitter but no power, and once they plug it into the Flyer they are able to send a message to Voyager. The ship heads back to pick them up.
On performance night, Kelis worries that his ending is not good enough to impress his patron. He sends a panicked message to B'Elanna, who comes back to help him end the play. She becomes an Eternal before the audience's very eyes when she is beamed away, making the play one that the patron will not forget.