Allison has a strange dream where Joe and the girls are all babies. The next day, Allison and Scanlon are called to the house of Scott and Dana Carlow who believe their housekeeper, Elizabeth, has kidnapped their baby, Bryce. Eerie baby noises lead Allison to a house where she finds Bryce in an oven. Allison has a strange feeling that she needs to keep the baby to protect him, but Joe makes her turn the baby into the police. Elizabeth's corpse turns up and her cousin Alberto identifies the body. Allison has a vision of Bryce's dead sister, Lucy, saying the baby isn't safe in the Carlows house. Allison maces Dana Carlow and kidnaps the baby at night, taking him to a hotel. Allison dreams that Alberto killed Elizabeth. She also dreams that Elizabeth had given Alberto the security code to the Carlow's home and that Alberto was going back to try to kidnap Bryce again. The police find Allison in the hotel and arrest her, but Dana visits her in jail saying that Alberto came the night before to try to kidnap the baby and Allison's intuitions were correct, so they are dropping the charges against her. Bridgette is jealous when Marie seems to be a prodigy, at the clarinet but it turns out Marie's own psychic abilities have helped her learn the ending to a song that will give the school music teacher peace after her father's death.