In the fall of 2008, Alicia and Scott Cain move into a four-bedroom home in Brookville, Ohio with their three children. The hauntings begin six months later when Alicia hears thumping noises. One afternoon, she finds her six-year-old daughter Marissa talking to an "imaginary friend" named Jacob who has a brother named Steven, both boys wearing sacks over their heads. She tells Alicia that the boys were caught in a fire and were burned alive. Alicia is convinced the house is haunted and does research of the previous owners and comes across info from 1865 that support what Marissa told her. Alicia goes to talk to a neighbor who tells her that some one was murdered there. Alicia obtains an article on the murder and learns that in the 1980s, a man had killed his wife. Paranormal investigators come in to capture voices. They call a priest, Allen Dershem, whom seemingly cleanses the house. Everything is normal until a week later when Alicia finds a blood trail leading to Marissa’s room and finds her with a big nose bleed. The family still continues to live in the house until they are financially able to move. Afterwards, the paranormal investigators hope to come back to perform an exorcism.