Newlywed lawyers Mclean and Suzanne bought a fixer upper, but four years and two kids later, their house is still in need of upgrades. Designer Hilary and Realtor David are ready to help. Hilary and her crew will tackle the structural changes of the house to make it work for their family. David will show the couple move-in ready homes to convince them to leave their first house. In the end, Mclean and Suzanne have to choose what to do with their house. Will they Love It? Or List It?