Maggie (Emma Grabinsky) is hopelessly infatuated with Brendon (Joel Semande), but he doesn't even notice her. When she messed up a chemical experiment, she meets Cupid (David DeLuise) – depicted as a man in a white suit instead of a boy or young man with wings, which he explains away as old photographs of himself – and commissions him to shoot an arrow at Brendon to make him fall for her, but when Maggie worries that the love potion will wear off, she asks Cupid for another hit, which he warns against, but does at her request which drives Brendan to go into a love-induced insanity. When she tries to break with him, he gets angry and chases her. When she asks Cupid for help, he says, 'You wanna be alone? You got it.' and pushes Brandon down the stairs. She tries to call for Cupid, but meets her nerdy classmate Stuart, who comforts her, saying she'll find love again soon, she turns to see Cupid shoot an arrow into her, causing her to fall in love with Stuart. Note: This is Grabinsky's third appearance since "Ghostly Stare" and "Creature Feature".