These are the shows I want to love but they seem to be lacking something or out of balance. In some cases the characters are under developed or the story drags along. It might even be the death of an important character has annoyed me or that the show has been classified as a comedy but it makes me feel sad. Whatever the case, it feels like these shows are under delivering or are not as satisfying as they could potentially be.
Shows that I got bored with or that got significantly worse over time. Some of them have specific moments that made me stop watching (I'm looking at you, Dexter). A split-off of my "TV Duds" list, since I felt a lot of these didn't deserve to be on there, since they were good at one point.