Agent DiGiacomo investigates a complaint about a starving dog in Brooklyn. DiGiacomo finds the emaciated dog in the boiler room of an apartment building. The super claims to have found the dog on the roof two weeks ago. The story takes an unexpected turn as DiGiacomo takes the dog out to her car, intending to take it to the ASPCA. A young man shouts from an upper window in the building that it is his dog, Gucci — and she's been missing for two months.