Special Investigator Diane DiGiacomo and Special Agent John De La Torre step in to save a young puppy that has been beaten by its owner on a Coney Island street. Tests at the ASPCA hospital reveal internal injuries as well as missing teeth and broken bones. Special Investigator Annemarie Lucas and undercover agent H are called in to assist Special Agent Tina Salaks when she discovers a dead goat and dead birds, along with a live goat and chickens, at a house in Brooklyn. The goat is thin and has signs of a viral infection, and there is evidence that it was intended for a religious sacrifice. Special Investigator Lucas is also involved in a case with Special Agent Joann Sandano where two dogs have fought each other, causing some nasty injuries. Finally, Special Investigator Diane DiGiacomo encounters Benji, a dog so badly matted it is barely recognizable.