Sometimes a homemade gift is better than anything money can buy, not often, but sometimes. Amy takes us deep into the craft room to give detailed instructions on: gluing things to popsicle sticks, working with pipe cleaners and surviving the craft room, "the most dangerous room in the house!" Amy presents her turtle sitter (Stephen Colbert) with a bevy of handmade gifts, and he reveals the moment of horror from his past that forever bonded him with turtles.