Conclusion. The Watcher's Council mistakenly abducts Buffy. Meanwhile, Faith (Eliza Dushku) fantasizes about killing Willow and later runs into Spike, who is amazed by her honesty. Joyce: Kristine Sutherland. Tara: Amber Benson. Anya: Emma Caulfield. Xander: Nicholas Brendon. Willow: Alyson Hannigan. Spike: James Marsters.