It's the fourth night in a week-long dinner party war. Tonight's host is proud Italian Nicole Pagnan. Joining her at the dinner table is couch potato Shawn Collins, chocolate specialist Amy Pagnucco, college professor Anna Bortolon, and poker player Chris McLoughlin. To get the night started, she serves a caprese soup appetizer. After pleasant reviews the main is plated and served; creamy risotto with prosciutto-wrapped halibut. Nicole adds a special touch with a live guitar player before serving her dessert; spicy dark chocolate crème brûlée. Will the Italian princess push it a hair too far or will she play it safe?