Sam and Jake break into Andy's house to find something of his to use for a reversal spell that will bring Andy back before anyone notices he is missing again. However, the spell does not work. When Alice confronts the boys, she tricks them by saying that they need Andy's elemental presence to complete the spell. After the spell is cast again, Felix, Sam and Jake seemingly summon back the water Andy, however it turns out to be a water demon who looks like him and chases after them. They later return to their welcome home party, where Andy's sister Viv and a police officer question them about Andy's whereabouts.