Albany, NY police respond to a 911 call and are shocked to find that a religious goods store owner and his employee have been brutally murdered in the store. A witness is able to give a description of someone running from the scene and dropping something into a garbage can, but police only find a bloody vestment. They scour the crime scene for evidence and even call in a K-9 unit to follow the killer's scent but the trail stops cold. With only one witness and few clues, investigators turn to psychic Ann Fisher to pick up the trail and help the police catch the vicious murdered.