A woman in Lamar, Colorado calls police to report her husband has gone missing. He was last seen meeting a potential buyer for the couple's car, Larry Wayne Shepherd, and police immediately suspect foul play. Detectives track down the suspicious buyer, but without any hard evidence they're forced to let Shepherd go. Desperate for leads, the detectives turn to psychic Phil Jordan to jumpstart the case. Phil's ominous visions point to murder, and it's up to the Lamar police department to put together the pieces of this puzzle.