The evil doll Lilly D. (from the series premiere "Really You") is back and out to get revenge on the family who discarded her. The doll is found by two boys and then give it to Natalie, a sweet girl who cleans her up and then her grandfather takes the doll to the "Really You" hospital, to repair her arm and the Dollmaker realizes that the doll has turned nice as she later brings the doll back to Natalie and the next day, Natalie finds a lonely baby bird and puts it in a shoebox, which makes the doll jealous and later in the night, the doll attempts to get it by using a stool, but falls and Natalie doesn't know what happened. The dolls in the basement tell the Dollmaker that Lily D. is still bad and then goes to try to save Natalie, but the doll drops a fish bowl on her head and Natalie starts to think about Lily D. and wants to get rid of her, but she hides and Later in the night, but Lilly D tries to drown the baby bird in the bathtub and later kicks Grandpa down the stairs. Natalie sees Lilly D in a wheelchair, but turns out to be a lamp and the doll behind her, has a knife as Natalie hits it out of her hand and then her head with a frying pan and then her head lands in a pot of water (while the dolls sing a lullaby) and then Natalie puts the pan on top of her head, meaning the doll is dead.