When Timmy visits his dad's office, he wishes a pencil that will last forever so that his father will get in better standings with his mean boss, Mr. Ed Leadly, but when Mr. Leadly finds out that it was Timmy came up with the everlasting pencil, he makes Timmy the new boss and his first tasks is to fire his dad; Timmy is trying out for the local soccer team, the Dimmsdale Victims, which are coached by his father, who wants to beat Dinkleberg's team, The Dinkle Ducks. However, Timmy costs his team the game and his father benches him. While eating his breakfast, Timmy accidentally swallows Poof who enters Timmy's brain and uses magic to enhance Timmy's skills, turning him into an all-star soccer player. Now Timmy must find a way to keep Cosmo and Wanda from finding Poof so that he can win the championship against Dinkleberg's team, or else they will take his magical powers away because Da Rules forbid cheating.