After Timmy tells Poof a scary story, the babies' crying keeps him up all night, so Timmy wishes for no light for twelve hours of day. Little does Timmy know, that when his godparents are kept in the dark for longer than eight hours, they become "Boogie Godparents" and turn on their godchild; After Dad gets lost while looking for their hotel and land on a deserted island, he struggles to make a boat to save his family to prove his masculinity and doesn't let anyone help him, while Poof finds a nuclear bomb in the sand and Cosmo activates it, putting the Turners' life is at risk.