Melissa-LeeM

Absolute BS...also can't stand Sarah Jessica Parker - she can't act.

Reading through the reviews I'm seeing alot of people saying it's the best of the Stargate franchise and that it was cancelled too soon. I'm sitting here watching it and thinking that it's another franchise that strayed too far from the original premise. I definitely prefer SG-1 & Atlantis over this load of rubbish. Robert Carlyle's character is just plain annoying and seems to do everything in his power to prevent everyone from finding a way home and comes across an egotistical, self-centered SOB who thinks that because he is smart then he should be the one in charge.

Gave it a shot, but couldn't get through the first episode - there just seemed to be something missing.

More enjoyable than I thought it would be.

I wasn't too sure about this in the beginning, but the story is starting to pick up and it's starting to get interesting. Am curious to see where this heads.

Third episode in and the characters still aren't doing it for me, and the storyline is weak. The female lead alone annoys me - couldn't the writers come up with a main female lead that didn't have to use her sexuality as part of her arsenal every episode? The brothers may have an interesting story if the writers let them and the show might be better without the female lead.

Four episodes in and it's starting to introduce some interesting twists. Going to keep watching.

Interesting concept. It seems to pick up a thread that could provide a decent storyline, but then drops it by the end of the episode.

Absolute rubbish. Bad script...bad acting...not worth the half-hour it takes up, let alone the hour in the winter.

One word - Strange. There are times when Patrick Bauchau's character in season one is reminiscent of his character Sydney in The Pretender.